2019 Diriyah ePrix explained

Type:	CUST
Next Round:	2020 Santiago ePrix
Country:	Saudi Arabia
Grand Prix:	Diriyah
Gp Suffix:	ePrix
Year:	2019
Official Name:	2019 Saudia Diriyah E-Prix
Location:	Riyadh Street Circuit, Diriyah, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
Course:	Street circuit
Course Length:	2.495km (01.55miles)
Distance Laps:	34
Distance Length:	77.345km (48.06miles)
Pole Driver:	Alexander Sims
Pole Country:	GBR
Pole Team:	Andretti-BMW
Pole Time:	1:14.563
Fast Driver:	Daniel Abt
Fast Team:	Audi
Fast Time:	1:13.742
Fast Lap:	22
Fast Country:	GER
First Driver:	Sam Bird
First Country:	GBR
First Team:	Virgin-Audi
Second Country:	GER
Second Team:	Porsche
Third Country:	BEL
Third Team:	Mercedes

Type:	CUST
Next Round:	2020 Santiago ePrix
Country:	Saudi Arabia
Grand Prix:	Diriyah
Gp Suffix:	ePrix
Year:	2019
Official Name:	2019 SAUDIA Diriyah E-Prix
Location:	Riyadh Street Circuit, Diriyah, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
Course:	Street circuit
Course Length:	2.495km (01.55miles)
Distance Laps:	30
Distance Length:	74.85km (46.51miles)
Pole Driver:	Alexander Sims
Pole Country:	GBR
Pole Team:	Andretti-BMW
Pole Time:	1:11.479
Fast Driver:	António Félix da Costa
Fast Team:	Techeetah-DS
Fast Time:	1:12.481
Fast Lap:	30
Fast Country:	PRT
First Driver:	Alexander Sims
First Country:	GBR
First Team:	Andretti-BMW
Second Country:	BRA
Second Team:	Audi
Third Country:	BEL
Third Team:	Mercedes

The 2019 Diriyah ePrix (officially the 2019 ABB FIA Formula E Saudia Diriyah ePrix) was a pair Formula E electric car race held at the Riyadh Street Circuit in the town of Diriyah, north-west of Riyadh, in Saudi Arabia on 22 and 23 November 2019. It formed the first and second rounds of the 2019–20 Formula E season and was the second edition of the Diriyah ePrix. The first race was won by Sam Bird with Andre Lotterer and Stoffel Vandoorne completing the podium.^[1] Alexander Sims won the second race.

Classification

Race one

Qualifying

Group draw^[2]
Group 1	JEV	BUE (2)	DIG (3)	FRI (4)	EVA (5)	DAC (6)
Group 2	ABT (7)	LOT (8)	BIR (9)	ROW (10)	DAM (11)	WEH (12)
Group 3	SIM (13)	MOR (14)	MAS (15)	VAN (16)	GUE (17)	TUR (20)
Group 4	HAR (–)	MUL (–)	DEV (–)	JAN (–)	CAL (–)	QMA (–)

		Driver	Team
1	27	data-sort-value="SIM"	Alexander Sims	Andretti-BMW	1:15.255	1:14.563	1
2	5	data-sort-value="VAN"	Stoffel Vandoorne	Mercedes	1:15.151	1:14.839	2
3	17	data-sort-value="DEV"	Nyck de Vries	Mercedes	1:15.027	1:14.929	3
4	48	data-sort-value="MOR"	Edoardo Mortara	Venturi-Mercedes	1:15.254	1:15.131	4
5	2	data-sort-value="BIR"	Sam Bird	Virgin-Audi	1:14.946	1:15.350	5
6	64	data-sort-value="DAM"	Jérôme d'Ambrosio	Mahindra	1:15.273	1:15.539	6
7	36	data-sort-value="LOT"	André Lotterer	Porsche	1:15.518		7
8	22	data-sort-value="ROW"	Oliver Rowland	e.dams-Nissan	1:15.653		8
9	28	data-sort-value="GUN"	Maximilian Günther	Andretti-BMW	1:15.680		9
10	3	data-sort-value="TUR"	Oliver Turvey	NIO	1:16.018		10
11	25	data-sort-value="VER"	Jean-Éric Vergne	Techeetah-DS	1:16.129		11
12	4	data-sort-value="FRI"	Robin Frijns	Virgin-Audi	1:16.200		12
13	94	data-sort-value="WEH"	Pascal Wehrlein	Mahindra	1:16.200		13
14	23	data-sort-value="BUE"	Sébastien Buemi	e.dams-Nissan	1:16.243		14
15	66	data-sort-value="ABT"	Daniel Abt	Audi	1:16.264		15
16	20	data-sort-value="EVA"	Mitch Evans	Jaguar	1:16.532		16
17	19	data-sort-value="MAS"	Felipe Massa	Venturi-Mercedes	1:16.583		17
18	6	data-sort-value="HAR"	Brendon Hartley	Dragon-Penske	1:17.074		18
19	11	data-sort-value="DIG"	Lucas di Grassi	Audi	1:17.213		19
20	18	data-sort-value="JAN"	Neel Jani	Porsche	1:17.745		20
21	13	data-sort-value="DAC"	António Félix da Costa	Techeetah-DS	1:18.613		21
22	33	data-sort-value="MA"	Ma Qinghua	NIO	1:21.701		22
DSQ	7	data-sort-value="MUL"	Nico Müller	Dragon-Penske	1:23.017		23
DSQ	51	data-sort-value="CAL"	James Calado	Jaguar	1:23.792		24
Source:^[3] ^[4] ^[5] ^[6]

Notes:

•  – Nico Müller and James Calado were disqualified from the session after disrespecting Parc fermé regulations in order to allow repairs to their damaged cars. The Stewards allowed Müller and Calado to start from the back of the grid.^{[7] [8]}

Race

		Driver	Team		Time/Retired		Points
1	2	data-sort-value="BIR"	Sam Bird	Virgin-Audi	34	46:17.371	5	25+1
2	36	data-sort-value="LOT"	André Lotterer	Porsche	34	+1.319	7	18
3	5	data-sort-value="VAN"	Stoffel Vandoorne	Mercedes	34	+1.672	2	15
4	22	data-sort-value="ROW"	Oliver Rowland	e.dams-Nissan	34	+1.944	8	12
5	4	data-sort-value="FRI"	Robin Frijns	Virgin-Audi	34	+3.983	12	10
6	17	data-sort-value="DEV"	Nyck de Vries	Mercedes	34	+4.560	3	8
7	48	data-sort-value="MOR"	Edoardo Mortara	Venturi-Mercedes	34	+5.122	4	6
8	27	data-sort-value="SIM"	Alexander Sims	Andretti-BMW	34	+5.715	1	4+3
9	64	data-sort-value="DAM"	Jérôme d'Ambrosio	Mahindra	34	+6.628	6	2
10	20	data-sort-value="EVA"	Mitch Evans	Jaguar	34	+7.048	16	1+1
11	94	data-sort-value="WEH"	Pascal Wehrlein	Mahindra	34	+7.460	13
12	19	data-sort-value="MAS"	Felipe Massa	Venturi-Mercedes	34	+8.166	17
13	11	data-sort-value="DIG"	Lucas di Grassi	Audi	34	+8.404	19
14	13	data-sort-value="DAC"	António Félix da Costa	Techeetah-DS	34	+8.853	21
15	3	data-sort-value="TUR"	Oliver Turvey	NIO	34	+10.172	10
16	51	data-sort-value="CAL"	James Calado	Jaguar	34	+11.572	24
17	18	data-sort-value="JAN"	Neel Jani	Porsche	34	+15.429	20
18	28	data-sort-value="GUN"	Maximilian Günther	Andretti-BMW	34	+25.662	8
19	6	data-sort-value="HAR"	Brendon Hartley	Dragon-Penske	34	+52.219	18
20	33	data-sort-value="MA"	Ma Qinghua	NIO	33	+1 lap	22
Ret	66	data-sort-value="ABT"	Daniel Abt	Audi	29	Accident	15
Ret	25	data-sort-value="VER"	Jean-Éric Vergne	Techeetah-DS	21	Steering	11
Ret	23	data-sort-value="BUE"	Sébastien Buemi	e.dams-Nissan	3	Technical	14
DNS	7	data-sort-value="MUL"	Nico Müller	Dragon-Penske	0	Did not start	23
Source:^[9]

Notes:

•  – Brendon Hartley received a ten-second time penalty for being unable to fulfill the complete time of the second attack mode.^[10]
•  – Ma Qinghua received a drive-through penalty converted into a 24-second time penalty for not respecting the homologated throttle pedal map.^[11]
•  – Fastest in group stage.
•  – Pole position.
•  – Fastest lap.

Standings after the race

Drivers' Championship standings

+/–		Driver	Points
	1	Sam Bird	26
	2	André Lotterer	18
	3	Stoffel Vandoorne	15
	4	Oliver Rowland	12
	5	Robin Frijns	10

Teams' Championship standings

+/–		Constructor	Points
	1	Virgin-Audi	36
	2	Mercedes	23
	3	Porsche	18
	4	e.Dams-Nissan	12
	5	BMW	7

• Notes: Only the top five positions are included for both sets of standings.

Race two

Qualifying

Group draw^[12]
Group 1	BIR	LOT (2)	VAN (3)	ROW (4)	FRI (5)	DEV (6)
Group 2	SIM (7)	MOR (8)	DAM (9)	EVA (10)	WEH (11)	MAS (12)
Group 3	DIG (13)	DAC (14)	TUR (15)	CAL (16)	JAN (17)	GUE (18)
Group 4	HAR (19)	QMA (20)	ABT (21)	JEV (22)	BUE (23)	MUL (24)

		Driver	Team
1	27	data-sort-value="SIM"	Alexander Sims	Andretti-BMW	1:11.858	1:11.476	1
2	23	data-sort-value="BUE"	Sébastien Buemi	e.dams-Nissan	1:11.774	1:11.696	2
3	11	data-sort-value="DIG"	Lucas di Grassi	Audi	1:11.939	1:11.784	3
4	64	data-sort-value="DAM"	Jérôme d'Ambrosio	Mahindra	1:11.835	1:12.093	4
5	13	data-sort-value="DAC"	António Félix da Costa	Techeetah-DS	1:11.418	1:14.134	5
6	20	data-sort-value="EVA"	Mitch Evans	Jaguar	1:11.972	data-sort-value="6"	no time	6
7	2	data-sort-value="BIR"	Sam Bird	Virgin-Audi	1:12.007		7
8	48	data-sort-value="MOR"	Edoardo Mortara	Venturi-Mercedes	1:12.008		8
9	28	data-sort-value="GUN"	Maximilian Günther	Andretti-BMW	1:12.051		9
10	36	data-sort-value="LOT"	André Lotterer	Porsche	1:12.153		10
11	25	data-sort-value="VER"	Jean-Éric Vergne	Techeetah-DS	1:12.327		24
12	5	data-sort-value="VAN"	Stoffel Vandoorne	Mercedes	1:12.422		11
13	4	data-sort-value="FRI"	Robin Frijns	Virgin-Audi	1:12.454		12
14	94	data-sort-value="WEH"	Pascal Wehrlein	Mahindra	1:12.635		13
15	66	data-sort-value="ABT"	Daniel Abt	Audi	1:12.642		14
16	19	data-sort-value="MAS"	Felipe Massa	Venturi-Mercedes	1:12.656		15
17	22	data-sort-value="ROW"	Oliver Rowland	e.dams-Nissan	1:12.660		16
18	3	data-sort-value="TUR"	Oliver Turvey	NIO	1:12.671		17
19	18	data-sort-value="JAN"	Neel Jani	Porsche	1:12.732		18
20	6	data-sort-value="HAR"	Brendon Hartley	Dragon-Penske	1:13.182		19
21	33	data-sort-value="MA"	Ma Qinghua	NIO	1:13.205		20
22	51	data-sort-value="CAL"	James Calado	Jaguar	1:13.430		21
23	7	data-sort-value="MUL"	Nico Müller	Dragon-Penske	1:13.703		22
24	17	data-sort-value="DEV"	Nyck de Vries	Mercedes	1:14.082		23
Source:^[13] ^[14]

Notes:

•  – Mitch Evans' car was found underweight after Super Pole, and his lap time was deleted.^[15]
•  – Jean-Éric Vergne received a twenty-place grid penalty for battery change, forcing him to start from the back of the grid.^[16] For being unable to take the full grid drop (by only losing thirteen places on the grid), he also received an additional drive-through penalty at the race.^[17]

Race

		Driver	Team		Time/Retired		Points
1	27	data-sort-value="SIM"	Alexander Sims	Andretti-BMW	30	46:48.327	1	25+3
2	11	data-sort-value="DIG"	Lucas di Grassi	Audi	30	+2.817	3	18
3	5	data-sort-value="VAN"	Stoffel Vandoorne	Mercedes	30	+3.581	11	15
4	48	data-sort-value="MOR"	Edoardo Mortara	Venturi-Mercedes	30	+4.294	8	12
5	22	data-sort-value="ROW"	Oliver Rowland	e.dams-Nissan	30	+5.475	16	10
6	66	data-sort-value="ABT"	Daniel Abt	Audi	30	+16.942	14	8
7	51	data-sort-value="CAL"	James Calado	Jaguar	30	+17.221	21	6
8	25	data-sort-value="VER"	Jean-Éric Vergne	Techeetah-DS	30	+19.394	24	4
9	6	data-sort-value="HAR"	Brendon Hartley	Dragon-Penske	30	+20.702	19	2
10	13	data-sort-value="DAC"	António Félix da Costa	Techeetah-DS	30	+22.634	5	1+1+1
11	28	data-sort-value="GUN"	Maximilian Günther	Andretti-BMW	30	+25.383	9
12	23	data-sort-value="BUE"	Sébastien Buemi	e.dams-Nissan	30	+26.291	2
13	18	data-sort-value="JAN"	Neel Jani	Porsche	30	+27.493	18
14	36	data-sort-value="LOT"	André Lotterer	Porsche	30	+29.046	10
15	94	data-sort-value="WEH"	Pascal Wehrlein	Mahindra	30	+35.290	13
16	17	data-sort-value="DEV"	Nyck de Vries	Mercedes	30	+36.318	23
17	19	data-sort-value="MAS"	Felipe Massa	Venturi-Mercedes	30	+45.758	15
18	20	data-sort-value="EVA"	Mitch Evans	Jaguar	30	+1:01.105	6
19	33	data-sort-value="MA"	Ma Qinghua	NIO	30	+1:28.165	20
Ret	7	data-sort-value="MUL"	Nico Müller	Dragon-Penske	28	Puncture	22
Ret	4	data-sort-value="FRI"	Robin Frijns	Virgin-Audi	18	Accident	12
Ret	2	data-sort-value="BIR"	Sam Bird	Virgin-Audi	13	Collision damage	7
DNS	64	data-sort-value="DAM"	Jérôme d'Ambrosio	Mahindra	0	Did not start	4
DSQ	3	data-sort-value="TUR"	Oliver Turvey	NIO	30	Energy usage	17
Source:^[18]

Notes:

•  – Maximilian Günther, André Lotterer and Mitch Evans all received a drive-through penalty converted into 24-second time penalties after overtaking cars under the yellow flag.^{[19] [20] [21]}
•  – Sébastien Buemi received a ten-second time penalty for unsafe rejoin to the track.^[22]
•  – Nyck de Vries received a five-second time penalty for a technical infringement.^[23] He then received a drive-through penalty converted into a 24-second time penalty after overtaking Oliver Turvey under the yellow flag.^[24]
•  – Felipe Massa received a drive-through penalty converted into a 24-second time penalty for speeding in the pit lane.^[25]
•  – Ma Qinghua received a drive-through penalty converted into a 24-second time penalty for causing a collision with Nico Müller.^[26] He then received a second drive-through penalty converted into a 24-second time penalty after overtaking four cars after the safety car procedure.^[27] Ma also received a five-second penalty before the race due to his battery being below 97% on the dummy grid.^[28]
•  – Oliver Turvey originally finished eighth and would have gotten promoted to sixth after all penalties having been applied, but was later disqualified as he used 40.06 kWh of total energy, exceeding the 40 kWh maximum.^[29]
•  – Pole position.
•  – Fastest in group stage; fastest lap.

Standings after the race

Drivers' Championship standings

+/–		Driver	Points
6	1	Alexander Sims	35
1	2	Stoffel Vandoorne	30
2	3	Sam Bird	26
	4	Oliver Rowland	22
8	5	Lucas di Grassi	18

Teams' Championship standings

+/–		Constructor	Points
1	1	Mercedes	38
1	2	Virgin-Audi	36
2	3	BMW	25
5	4	Audi	26
1	5	e.Dams-Nissan	22

• Notes: Only the top five positions are included for both sets of standings.

References

|- style="text-align:center"|width="35%"|Previous race:
2019 New York City ePrix|width="30%"|FIA Formula E Championship
2019–20 season|width="35%"|Next race:
2020 Santiago ePrix|- style="text-align:center"|width="35%"|Previous race:
2018 Ad Diriyah ePrix|width="30%"|Diriyah ePrix|width="35%"|Next race:
2021 Diriyah ePrix|- style="text-align:center"

Notes and References

1. News: Formula E: Sam Bird wins Saudi E-Prix. 2019-11-22. BBC Sport. 2019-11-22. en-GB.
2. Web site: Doc 24 - Qualifying Groups. FIA Formula E. 22 November 2019.
3. Web site: Doc 42 - Classification Qualifying. FIA Formula E. 22 November 2019.
4. Web site: Doc 43 - Classification Qualifying Superpole. FIA Formula E. 22 November 2019.
5. Web site: Doc 52 - Final Classification Qualifying. FIA Formula E. 22 November 2019.
6. Web site: Doc 53 - Starting Grid RACE. FIA Formula E. 22 November 2019.
7. Web site: Doc 48 - Decision 14. FIA Formula E. 22 November 2019.
8. Web site: Doc 50 - Decision 15. FIA Formula E. 22 November 2019.
9. Web site: Doc 64 - Final Classification RACE. FIA Formula E. 22 November 2019.
10. Web site: Doc 60 - Decision 19. FIA Formula E. 22 November 2019.
11. Web site: Doc 62 - Decision 21. FIA Formula E. 22 November 2019.
12. Web site: Doc 69 - Qualifying Groups - Round 2. FIA Formula E. 23 November 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20200102070545/https://fe-noticeboard.s3.amazonaws.com/05_2019-20/01_R01%20Diriyah/ABB%20FIA%20Formula%20E%20Championship/69_Doc%2069%20-%20Qualifying%20Groups%20-%20Round%202.pdf. 2 January 2020. dead.
13. Web site: Doc 83 - Classification Qualifying - Superpole. FIA Formula E. 23 November 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20200102070606/https://fe-noticeboard.s3.amazonaws.com/05_2019-20/01_R01%20Diriyah/ABB%20FIA%20Formula%20E%20Championship/83_Doc%2083%20-%20Final%20Classifiaction%20Qualifying%20-%20Superpole.pdf. 2 January 2020. dead.
14. Web site: Doc 84 - Final Starting Grid Race. FIA Formula E. 23 November 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20200102070611/https://fe-noticeboard.s3.amazonaws.com/05_2019-20/01_R01%20Diriyah/ABB%20FIA%20Formula%20E%20Championship/84_Doc%2084%20-%20Final%20Starting%20Grid%20Race.pdf. 2 January 2020. dead.
15. Web site: Doc 79 - Decision 26. FIA Formula E. 23 November 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20200102070652/https://fe-noticeboard.s3.amazonaws.com/05_2019-20/01_R01%20Diriyah/ABB%20FIA%20Formula%20E%20Championship/79_Doc%2079%20-%20Decision%20No.%2026.pdf. 2 January 2020. dead.
16. Web site: Doc 75 - Decision 25. FIA Formula E. 24 November 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20200102070647/https://fe-noticeboard.s3.amazonaws.com/05_2019-20/01_R01%20Diriyah/ABB%20FIA%20Formula%20E%20Championship/75_Doc%2075%20-%20Decision%2025.pdf. 2 January 2020. dead.
17. DSTECHEETAH . 1198213037968232448 . 23 November 2019 . JEV has served his 10 second drive through and is back out on track. Time to pass some cars. DAC is running P4. .
18. Web site: Doc 106 - Final Classification RACE. FIA Formula E. 23 November 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20200102070550/https://fe-noticeboard.s3.amazonaws.com/05_2019-20/01_R01%20Diriyah/ABB%20FIA%20Formula%20E%20Championship/106_Doc%20106%20-%20FInal%20Classification%20RACE.pdf. 2 January 2020. dead.
19. Web site: Doc 100 - Decision 40. FIA Formula E. 23 November 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20200102070616/https://fe-noticeboard.s3.amazonaws.com/05_2019-20/01_R01%20Diriyah/ABB%20FIA%20Formula%20E%20Championship/100_Doc%20100%20-%20Decision%20No.%2040.pdf. 2 January 2020. dead.
20. Web site: Doc 103 - Decision 35 AMENDED. FIA Formula E. 23 November 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20200102070631/https://fe-noticeboard.s3.amazonaws.com/05_2019-20/01_R01%20Diriyah/ABB%20FIA%20Formula%20E%20Championship/103_Doc%20103%20-%20Decision%20No.%2035%20AMENDED.pdf. 2 January 2020. dead.
21. Web site: Doc 103 - Decision 43. FIA Formula E. 23 November 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20200102070729/https://fe-noticeboard.s3.amazonaws.com/05_2019-20/01_R01%20Diriyah/ABB%20FIA%20Formula%20E%20Championship/103_Doc%20103%20-%20Decision%20No.%2043.pdf. 2 January 2020. dead.
22. Web site: Doc 89 - Decision 31. FIA Formula E. 23 November 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20200102070704/https://fe-noticeboard.s3.amazonaws.com/05_2019-20/01_R01%20Diriyah/ABB%20FIA%20Formula%20E%20Championship/89_Doc%2089%20-%20Decision%20No.%2031.pdf. 2 January 2020. dead.
23. Web site: Doc 96 - Decision 38. FIA Formula E. 23 November 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20200102070718/https://fe-noticeboard.s3.amazonaws.com/05_2019-20/01_R01%20Diriyah/ABB%20FIA%20Formula%20E%20Championship/96_Doc%2096%20-%20Decision%20No.%2038.pdf. 2 January 2020. dead.
24. Web site: Doc 102 - Decision 42. FIA Formula E. 23 November 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20200102070626/https://fe-noticeboard.s3.amazonaws.com/05_2019-20/01_R01%20Diriyah/ABB%20FIA%20Formula%20E%20Championship/102_Doc%20102%20-%20Decision%20No.%2042.pdf. 2 January 2020. dead.
25. Web site: Doc 94 - Decision 36. FIA Formula E. 23 November 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20200102070709/https://fe-noticeboard.s3.amazonaws.com/05_2019-20/01_R01%20Diriyah/ABB%20FIA%20Formula%20E%20Championship/94_Doc%2094%20-%20Decision%20No.%2036.pdf. 2 January 2020. dead.
26. Web site: Doc 95 - Decision 37. FIA Formula E. 23 November 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20200102070713/https://fe-noticeboard.s3.amazonaws.com/05_2019-20/01_R01%20Diriyah/ABB%20FIA%20Formula%20E%20Championship/95_Doc%2095%20-%20Decision%20No.%2037.pdf. 2 January 2020. dead.
27. Web site: Doc 101 - Decision 41. FIA Formula E. 23 November 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20200102070621/https://fe-noticeboard.s3.amazonaws.com/05_2019-20/01_R01%20Diriyah/ABB%20FIA%20Formula%20E%20Championship/101_Doc%20101%20-%20Decision%20No.%2041.pdf. 2 January 2020. dead.
28. Web site: Doc 86 - Decision 28. FIA Formula E. 23 November 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20200102070659/https://fe-noticeboard.s3.amazonaws.com/05_2019-20/01_R01%20Diriyah/ABB%20FIA%20Formula%20E%20Championship/86_Doc%2086%20-%20Decision%2028.pdf. 2 January 2020. dead.
29. Web site: Doc 98 - Decision 39. FIA Formula E. 23 November 2019. https://web.archive.org/web/20200102070724/https://fe-noticeboard.s3.amazonaws.com/05_2019-20/01_R01%20Diriyah/ABB%20FIA%20Formula%20E%20Championship/98_Doc%2098%20-%20Decision%20No.%2039.pdf. 2 January 2020. dead.