2018 Marseille building collapse explained

2018 collapse of Rue d'Aubagne
Date:5 November 2018
Place:Marseille, France
Reported Death(S):8

At 9am on November 5, 2018, two buildings in Marseille, numbers 63 and 65 Rue d'Aubagne, collapsed in the center of Marseille,[1] [2] killing eight people in the crowded neighborhood of Noailles. Number 63 was unoccupied, belonging since 2016 to the economic improvement company Marseille Habitat, but number 65 was occupied with people living in the building. Eight bodies were found in the rubble,[3] [4] [5] when the search for survivors came to an end on 9 November. Emergency services immediately demolished the building next to number 67, as it was unoccupied and equally fragile.

The local government, overwhelmed by the management of this drama, evacuated at least 4,500 Marseille locals from 578 dangerous buildings during the months following the accident, but many are still lodged in their "temporary" housing. Most of the evacuees were from the ethnic minorities living in these buildings, and were moved from their houses to safer accommodation.[6] The management crisis became the norm: one year after the accident, the "Haute Comité au logement" spoke of a humanitarian crisis. Three years after the accident, 1,500 people still live in their temporary lodging.

After the collapse, the tenants of the houses in the center of Marseille cited laziness on the part of the town hall because most buildings in the center of Marseille are dilapidated and not maintained.[7]

During a march to honour the victims on 10 November, which gathered 8,000 people, according to the authorities, a balcony collapsed, injuring three.[8]

The indictments began in November 2020 with those of Marseille Habitat (owner of No. 63), Julien Ruas (close to Jean-Claude Gaudin and his deputy in charge of the risk management and prevention department), and the Liautard firm (co-ownership manager in charge of No. 65). The investigation could last for many years.[9]

The dilapidation of Marseille's housing

The accident revealed the dilapidated state of Marseille's housing [10] [11] (100,000 Marseillais live in slums according to the Fondation Abbé Pierre, and 13% of Marseille's housing is considered to be substandard), as well as the mayor's inaction.[12] [13] [14]

In 2015, a report from the honorary inspector general of the administration of sustainable development titled "Private Real Estate in Marseille"[15] ordered and made public by the minister of housing, Silvia Pinel,[16] had already overwhelmed the municipality. It concluded that "100,000 people live in unsanitary housing in Marseille."[17] [18]

After the collapse, the Haut comité pour le logement des personnes défavorisées (High Committee for the Housing of Disadvantaged Persons) publicized on 21 November a report submitted to President Emmanuel Macron and Prime Minister Édouard Philippe with the evocative title "Marseille: From Housing to Humanitarian Crisis."[19] [20] In the report, it is claimed that "the collapses of the buildings on rue d'Aubagne were not accidental and unforeseeable events. They resulted from a continuity of dysfunction from public actors," thus pointing the finger at the City Council and the French government, reminding that "the prefect could have given the city formal notice to investigate the claims of the city's insalubrity."[21]

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Marseille building collapse: four bodies found as search continues. Willsher. Kim. 2018-11-06. the Guardian. en. 2018-11-10.
  2. Web site: Marseille: the psychosis settles after the collapse of the rue d'aubagne The Koz Post. kozpost.com. en-US. 2018-11-10. https://web.archive.org/web/20181111001802/https://kozpost.com/blog/marseille-the-psychosis-settles-after-the-collapse-of-the-rue-daubagne/15364/. 2018-11-11. dead.
  3. News: Death Toll in Marseille Building Collapse Rises to 6. 2018-11-20. en.
  4. Web site: Marseille building collapse: sixth body found in rubble. Willsher. Kim. 2018-11-07. the Guardian. en. 2018-11-11.
  5. News: Death toll up to 8 in Marseille building collapse. ABC News. 2018-11-11. en. https://web.archive.org/web/20181111173711/https://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory/death-toll-marseille-building-collapse-59083204. 2018-11-11. dead.
  6. News: As Slums Teeter in Marseille, a Poverty Crisis Turns Deadly. 2018-11-20. en.
  7. News: Avant l'effondrement des immeubles, la gestion de l'habitat par la mairie de Marseille déjà critiquée. Le Monde.fr. 2018-11-12. fr-FR.
  8. Web site: Marseille building collapse: balcony gives way as city honours victims. 2018-11-11.
  9. Web site: Harounyan. Stéphanie. Drame de la rue d'Aubagne: deux mises en examen de plus. 2021-09-21. Libération. fr.
  10. https://www.lemonde.fr/societe/article/2018/11/06/habitat-indigne-dans-le-centre-ville-de-marseille-comment-en-est-on-arrive-la_5379674_3224.html Dans le centre-ville de Marseille, 13 % de l'habitat est indigne
  11. https://www.franceculture.fr/histoire/incurie-municipale-a-marseille-quand-la-cite-phoceenne-passait-sous-tutelle-de-letat Incurie municipale à Marseille ? Quand la cité phocéenne passait sous tutelle de l'État
  12. François Bonnet, A Marseille, une mairie incompeténte et un Etat absent, Mediapart, 6 November 2018
  13. https://www.lemonde.fr/police-justice/article/2018/11/08/marseille-recherches-suspendues-pour-demolir-deux-immeubles-voisins-gaudin-doit-s-exprimer_5380554_1653578.html Effondrement d'un immeuble à Marseille: critiqué, le maire Jean-Claude Gaudin défend les efforts de la ville
  14. Immeubles effondrés à Marseille: Laisser pourrir le quartier Noailles procède d'une stratégie politique, Le Monde, 22 November 2018
  15. http://www.cres-paca.org/arkotheque/client/crespaca/thematiques/detail_document.php?ref=1668&titre=parc-immobilier-prive-a-marseille-rapport-de-christian-nicol&from=themes "Parc immobilier privé à Marseille: rapport de Christian Nicol - CRES Paca"
  16. https://marsactu.fr/logement-indigne-a-marseille-un-rapport-au-vitriol/ Logement indigne à Marseille: un rapport au vitriol
  17. https://www.laprovence.com/article/societe/5229548/effondrements-dimmeubles-a-marseille-logement-insalubre-un-constat-terrible.html Effondrements d'immeubles à Marseille: logement insalubre, un constat terrible
  18. News: 2018-11-05. Marseille: dix personnes introuvables après l'effondrement de deux immeubles. fr. Le Monde.fr. 2021-09-21.
  19. https://www.lemonde.fr/societe/article/2019/11/21/a-marseille-la-crise-du-logement-est-desormais-une-veritable-crise-humanitaire_6020007_3224.html A Marseille, la crise du logement est désormais «une véritable crise humanitaire
  20. David Coquille, A Marseille, la crise du logement est une crise humanitaire - Journal La Marseillaise
  21. https://www.liberation.fr/france/2019/11/05/marseille-le-haut-comite-au-logement-demolit-l-action-publique_1761783/ Marseille : le Haut Comité au logement démolit l'action publique

This article is licensed under the GNU Free Documentation License. It uses material from the Wikipedia article "2018 Marseille building collapse".

Except where otherwise indicated, Everything.Explained.Today is © Copyright 2009-2024, A B Cryer, All Rights Reserved. Cookie policy.