2011 New South Wales state election explained

Election Name:2011 New South Wales state election
Country:New South Wales
Type:parliamentary
Ongoing:no
Previous Election:2007 New South Wales state election
Previous Year:2007
Next Election:2015 New South Wales state election
Next Year:2015
Seats For Election:All 93 seats in the New South Wales Legislative Assembly
and 21 (of the 42) seats in the New South Wales Legislative Council
47 Assembly seats were needed for a majority
Election Date:26 March 2011
Opinion Polls:
  1. Opinion polling
Leader1:Barry O'Farrell
Leader Since1:4 April 2007
Party1:Liberal/National coalition
Leaders Seat1:Ku-ring-gai
Popular Vote1:2,124,321
Percentage1:51.15%
Swing1: 14.16
Last Election1:35 seats
Seats Before1:37
Seats Needed1: 10
Seats1:69
Seat Change1: 32
Leader2:Kristina Keneally
Leader Since2:4 December 2009
Party2:Australian Labor Party (New South Wales Branch)
Leaders Seat2:Heffron
Popular Vote2:1,061,352
Percentage2:25.55%
Swing2: 13.43
Last Election2:52 seats
Seats Before2:50
Seats2:20
Seat Change2: 30
Leader3:No leader
Party3:The Greens NSW
Popular Vote3:427,144
Percentage3:10.29%
Swing3: 1.33
Last Election3:0 seats
Seats Before3:0
Seats Needed3: 46
Seats3:1
Seat Change3: 1
1Blank:TPP
1Data1:64.22%
1Data2:35.78%
2Blank:TPP swing
2Data1: 16.48
2Data2: 16.48
Map Size:400px
Premier
Before Election:Kristina Keneally
Before Party:Australian Labor Party (New South Wales Branch)
Posttitle:Elected Premier
After Election:Barry O'Farrell
After Party:Liberal/National coalition

The 2011 New South Wales state election held on Saturday, 26 March 2011. The 16-year-incumbent Labor Party government led by Premier Kristina Keneally was defeated in a landslide by the LiberalNational Coalition opposition led by Barry O'Farrell.

Labor suffered a two-party swing of 16.4 points, the largest against a sitting government at any level in Australia since World War II. From 50 seats at dissolution, Labor was knocked down to 20 seats—the worst defeat of a sitting government in New South Wales history, and one of the worst of a state government in Australia since federation. The Coalition picked up a 32-seat swing to win a strong majority, with 69 seats–the largest majority government, in terms of percentage of seats controlled, in NSW history. It is only the third time since 1941 that a NSW Labor government has been defeated. It was also notable in that many of Labor's safest seats, such as the seat of Newcastle, were won by the Liberal Party for the first time in history. This election also saw the previous record for largest percentage of seats defeated by the Coalition winning 74.2 percent of seats (69 out of 93 seats) with the previous record set by Neville Wran's Labor Party in the 1981 election, in which Labor won 69 out of 99 seats (69.7 percent).

New South Wales has compulsory voting, with an optional preferential ballot in single-member seats for the lower house and single transferable vote with optional preferential above-the-line voting in the proportionally represented upper house. The election was conducted by the New South Wales Electoral Commission (NSWEC).

Background

See also: Post-election pendulum for the New South Wales state election, 2007. The centre-left Labor Party, led by Premier Kristina Keneally, and the centre-right Liberal Party, led by Leader of the Opposition Barry O'Farrell, were the two main parties in New South Wales. In the 2007 state election, of 93 seats total, Labor won 52 seats, the Liberals won 22 seats and the Nationals, led by Andrew Stoner, who are in coalition with the Liberals, won 13 seats. Six seats were retained by independents. Smaller parties which hold no seats in the lower house but achieved significant votes in 2007 include The Greens and the Christian Democratic Party.

On 18 October 2008, four state electorates (Lakemba, Ryde, Cabramatta, Port Macquarie) went to by-elections as a result of the resignation of the Premier, two of his ministers, and an independent who left after winning a federal by-election. The results in Ryde, Cabramatta, and Lakemba showed the largest by-election swing against Labor in its history.[1] The results showed a significant swing towards the Liberal Party with a swing of 22.7 percentage points in former health minister Reba Meagher's seat of Cabramatta, but it was retained by ALP candidate Nick Lalich,[1] and a swing of 13 points against Labor in former premier Morris Iemma's seat of Lakemba, also retained by an ALP candidate, Robert Furolo.[1] Ryde, once a safe Labor seat, with a swing of 23.1 points delivered former deputy premier John Watkins' seat to Victor Dominello. Peter Besseling, the independent candidate, won Port Macquarie, left vacant after the resignation of Nationals-turned-independent member Rob Oakeshott, over the Nationals by a two-party margin of 54.5–45.5%, despite a swing of 23.7 points to the Nationals. On 19 June 2010 a by-election in the electoral district of Penrith[2] was triggered as a result of the resignation of Labor Party MP Karyn Paluzzano, with Liberal candidate Stuart Ayres winning the seat with a two-party-preferred swing of more than 25 points, the biggest swing against an incumbent government in New South Wales history, until the 2013 Miranda by-election which eclipsed it with a 26-point two-party swing against the Liberal/National government.[3]

Key dates

Campaign

See also: Candidates of the 2011 New South Wales state election. The Labor Party launched their campaign on 5 February 2011[5] in Liverpool within the electoral district of Macquarie Fields.[6] Premier Keneally launched the Labor Party's campaign slogan "Protecting jobs – Supporting families". In attendance for the launch were former Prime Minister Bob Hawke and former Premiers Wran and Carr.

The Liberal and Nationals Coalition launched their campaign on 20 February 2011 at the Joan Sutherland Performing Arts Centre in Penrith within the electoral district of Penrith with the slogan: "Real Change for NSW". In attendance for the launch were both Liberal and Nationals Leaders O'Farrell and Stoner as well as federal Liberal Party leader Tony Abbott, former Liberal Premiers and Leaders Greiner, Fahey, and Chikarovski.[7]

The Coalition had been leading in opinion polling for almost three years, and were unbackable favourites throughout the campaign to win the election. The final Newspoll had support for Labor at an all-time low with 23 percent of the primary vote and 35.9 percent of the two-party vote. Bookmakers were paying $1.01 for a Coalition win with Labor getting as much as $36 and one agency even paid out the winnings and declared the winner a week earlier.[8] At one point, Labor was widely predicted to win as few as 13 seats, seven less than the actual result.[9] According to several pollsters, Labor was in danger of losing several seats where it had not been seriously threatened in decades, as well as several that it had held for a century or more. Indeed, there were concerns that Labor would not win enough seats to form a credible shadow cabinet.

Resulting parliament

The Liberal/National Coalition won the largest proportional number of seats in NSW state history with 69 of 93 seats in the lower house (74.2 percent of the chamber)—in contrast, Labor won 69 of 99 seats (69.7 percent of the chamber) at Neville Wran's second "Wranslide" in 1981 election. Labor won 20 seats, the lowest for Labor in NSW Parliament in over a century, and the worst defeat that a sitting government in NSW has ever suffered. Many prominent Labor MPs and ministers lost their seats including Verity Firth, David Borger, Matt Brown, Jodi McKay, Virginia Judge, Phil Costa and Kevin Greene.[10] In the process, the Coalition took dozens of seats in areas considered Labor heartland, such as western Sydney and the Upper Hunter—some on swings of well over 10 per cent. The Liberals actually won 51 seats, enough for a majority in their own right—the first time the main non-Labor party in the state had achieved this since adopting the Liberal banner in 1945. Although O'Farrell thus had no need for the support of the Nationals, he opted to retain the Coalition.

In the upper house however, where half of the chamber was up for election, the landslide was not enough to deliver a Coalition majority. Three additional votes outside of the Liberal/National Coalition were required to pass legislation. The balance of power shifted from the Greens to the Shooters and Fishers Party and Christian Democratic Party. With two seats each held by the latter two parties, both needed to give legislative support if Labor and the Greens opposed legislation.[11] [12]

Retiring members

Where a Member of the Legislative Assembly or Legislative Council did not renominate to contest the election, their term ended at the dissolution of the parliament. Members who confirmed their retirement were:

Legislative Assembly

Labor (22)

Liberal (5)

Nationals (2)

Legislative Council

Labor (4)

Greens (1)

Opinion polling

Opinion polling was conducted by firms such as Newspoll, Galaxy and Nielsen via random telephone number selection in city and country areas Sampling sizes consist of around 1200–1300 electors. The declared margin of error is ±3 percentage points.

Graphical summary

Primary votes

Two-party preferred

Voting intention

+Legislative Assembly polling
DateFirmPrimary voteTPP vote
ALPL/NPGRNOTHALPL/NP
26 March 2011Nielsen22%50%13%15%36%64%
21-24 March 2011Newspoll23%49%12%15%35.9%64.1%
23 March 2011Galaxy22%51%12%15%34%64%
23 March 2011Essential23%55%11%11%34%66%
18 March 2011Essential24%54%12%11%35%65%
9-11 March 2011Newspoll26%50%11%13%37%63%
4 March 2011Galaxy23%50%14%13%36%64%
18 February 2011Essential27%51%12%10%41%59%
Jan-Feb 2011Newspoll23%46%17%14%38%62%
16 February 2011Nielsen22%53%13%12%34%66%
20 January 2011Nielsen20%51%15%14%34%66%
Nov-Dec 2010Newspoll23%46%17%14%37%63%
Oct-Dec 2010Morgan22%53%13.5%11.5%35%65%
Sep-Oct 2010Newspoll23%46%17%14%37%63%
Jul-Aug 2010Newspoll25%46%14%15%39%61%
May-Jun 2010Newspoll25%46%16%12%39%61%
Mar-Apr 2010Newspoll31%42%14%13%45%55%
22 March 2010Galaxy29%44%14%13%43%57%
14 January 2010Galaxy29%43%15%13%44%56%
4 December 2009 Kristina Keneally replaces Nathan Rees as Labor leader and Premier
Nov-Dec 2009Newspoll26%44%17%13%41%59%
28 November 2009Taverner31%43%26%45%55%
Sep-Oct 2009Newspoll30%42%12%16%45%55%
Jul-Aug 2009Newspoll32%41%14%13%46%54%
May-Jun 2009Newspoll31%41%14%14%45%55%
31 May 2009Taverner44%56%
Mar-Apr 2009Newspoll33%40%13%14%47%53%
Jan-Feb 2009Newspoll30%42%15%13%44%56%
Nov-Dec 2008Newspoll26%43%14%17%41%59%
Sep-Oct 2008Newspoll29%42%11%18%44%56%
5 September Nathan Rees replaces Morris Iemma as Labor leader and Premier
Jul-Aug 2008Newspoll33%40%13%14%48%52%
29 June 2008Taverner28%46%26%44%56%
May-Jun 2008Newspoll32%41%13%14%48%52%
Mar-Apr 2008Newspoll35%38%14%13%51%49%
Jan-Mar 2008Newspoll34%39%14%13%50%50%
15-19 February 2008Nielsen38%42%11%9%50%50%
2 February 2008Taverner51%49%
4 April 2007 Barry O'Farrell succeeds Peter Debnam as Liberal leader and Leader of the Opposition
24 March 2007 election38.98%36.99%8.95%15.08% 52.26%47.74%
23 March 2007Nielsen41%36%10%13%56%44%

Better Premier and satisfaction

Graphical summary

+ Better Premier and satisfaction polling*
DateFirmBetter PremierKeneallyO'Farrell
KeneallyO'FarrellSatisfiedDissatisfiedSatisfiedDissatisfied
26 March 2011Nielsen37%53%37%54%53%34%
21-24 March 2011Newspoll32%48%33%59%48%39%
23 March 2011Galaxy33%53%
4 March 2011Galaxy34%50%
Jan-Feb 2011Newspoll32%47%30%57%43%35%
16 February 2011Nielsen38%52%36%58%55%33%
14 January 2011Galaxy32%54%30%62%53%33%
Nov-Dec 2010Newspoll35%40%35%49%42%33%
Sep-Oct 2010Newspoll35%42%39%50%48%32%
Jul-Aug 2010Newspoll39%39%39%44%43%33%
May-Jun 2010Newspoll44%36%47%37%44%33%
Mar-Apr 2010Newspoll45%30%47%31%41%34%
22 March 2010Galaxy48%35%53%30%44%36%
Jan-Feb 2010Newspoll40%31%41%26%44%30%
14 January 2010Galaxy42%34%45%25%42%35%
Nov-Dec 2009Newspoll35%34%44%30%
4 December 2009 Keneally replaces ReesReesO'FarrellReesO'Farrell
28 November 2009Nielsen43%40%39%49%44%36%
Jul-Aug 2009Newspoll32%33%33%51%36%36%
May-Jun 2009Newspoll33%32%30%49%34%34%
31 May 2009Taverner33%50%
Mar-Apr 2009Newspoll33%31%34%46%35%37%
Jan-Feb 2009Newspoll34%29%37%42%39%32%
Nov-Dec 2008Newspoll30%33%34%47%40%32%
Sep-Oct 2008Newspoll35%28%39%26%41%30%
5 September 2008 Rees replaces Iemma IemmaO'FarrellIemmaO'Farrell
May-Jun 2008Newspoll32%39%26%63%37%34%
Mar-Apr 2008Newspoll36%33%28%56%33%34%
19 February 2008Nielsen45%30%34%44%not asked
17 February 2008Taverner51%29%18%19%
4 April 2007 O'Farrell replaces DebnamIemmaDebnamIemmaDebnam
24 March 2007 election
22 March 2007Newspoll58%24%47%43%31%55%
  • Remainder were "uncommitted", "fair" or "other/neither".

Newspaper endorsements

NewspaperEndorsement
The Australian[13]
The Australian Financial Review
Newcastle Herald
The Daily Telegraph[14]
The Sydney Morning Herald[15]

Results

Legislative Assembly

See main article: Results of the 2011 New South Wales state election (Legislative Assembly).

PartyVotes%SwingSeatsChange
  align=left Liberal1,602,45738.58+11.64 51 27
 align=left National521,86412.56+2.51 18 5
Coalition total2,124,32151.15+14.1669style=text-align:right; 32
 Labor1,061,35225.55–13.43 20 30
 Greens427,14410.28+1.33 1 1
 Christian Democrats129,4313.12+0.650
 Hatton's Independent Team45,9691.10+1.100
 Family First18,5760.45+0.450
 Socialist Alliance3,1800.07+0.070
 Social Justice Network3,1730.07+0.070
 Independent Australia First2,4460.06+0.060
 Socialist Equality2,0560.05+0.050
 Democratic Labor1,8550.04+0.040
 United We Stand1,4140.03+0.030
 Progressive Labour1,3720.03+0.030
 Communist League1,2260.03+0.030
 Sex Party6760.02+0.020
 Democrats6170.01–0.390
 Independent Protectionist2890.01+0.010
 Independents314,0667.56–1.623 3
 Formal votes4,153,33596.72+0.18
 Informal votes137,2603.20+0.43
 Total 4,290,59593
 Registered voters / turnout4,635,81092.55–0.09
Two-party-preferred vote
Coalition2,324,22664.22+16.48
Labor1,294,824 35.78–16.48

Legislative Council

See main article: Results of the 2011 New South Wales state election (Legislative Council).

Seats changing hands

SeatPre-2011SwingPost-2011
PartyMemberMarginMarginMemberParty
Balmain LaborVerity Firth3.7–7.23.5*Jamie ParkerGreens 
Bathurst LaborGerard Martin13.0–36.723.7Paul TooleNational 
Blue Mountains LaborPhil Koperberg11.1–15.84.7Roza SageLiberal 
Camden LaborGeoff Corrigan3.9–22.818.9Chris PattersonLiberal 
Campbelltown LaborGraham West18.5–21.93.4Bryan DoyleLiberal 
Charlestown LaborMatthew Morris14.6–24.59.9Andrew CornwellLiberal 
Coogee LaborPaul Pearce7.2–15.48.2Bruce Notley-SmithLiberal 
Dubbo IndependentDawn Fardell0.9–14.613.7Troy GrantNational 
Drummoyne LaborAngela D'Amore7.6–24.316.7John SidotiLiberal 
East Hills LaborAlan Ashton14.1–14.70.6Glenn BrookesLiberal 
Gosford LaborMarie Andrews4.9–16.711.9Chris HolsteinLiberal 
Granville LaborDavid Borger11.1–13.72.6Tony IssaLiberal 
Heathcote LaborPaul McLeay8.8–21.412.7Lee EvansLiberal 
Kiama LaborMatt Brown12.0–19.57.5Gareth WardLiberal 
Londonderry LaborAllan Shearan6.9–19.212.3Bart BassettLiberal 
Maitland LaborFrank Terenzini9.7–16.06.3Robyn ParkerLiberal 
Menai LaborAlison Megarrity2.7–27.124.4Melanie GibbonsLiberal 
Miranda LaborBarry Collier0.8–21.821.0Graham AnnesleyLiberal 
Monaro LaborSteve Whan6.3–8.32.0John BarilaroNational 
Mulgoa LaborDiane Beamer11.1–23.212.0Tanya DaviesLiberal 
Newcastle LaborJodi McKay1.2–3.62.4Tim OwenLiberal 
Oatley LaborKevin Greene14.4–14.90.5Mark CoureLiberal 
Parramatta LaborTanya Gadiel13.7–25.812.1Geoff LeeLiberal 
Port Macquarie IndependentPeter Besseling28.2**–35.16.9Leslie WilliamsNational 
Riverstone LaborJohn Aquilina10.1–30.320.2Kevin ConollyLiberal 
Rockdale LaborFrank Sartor10.3–13.93.6John FlowersLiberal 
Smithfield LaborNinos Khoshaba15.5–20.34.8Andrew RohanLiberal 
Strathfield LaborVirginia Judge15.1–19.34.3Charles CasuscelliLiberal 
Swansea LaborRobert Coombs10.8–11.91.1Garry EdwardsLiberal 
Tamworth IndependentPeter Draper4.8–12.57.8Kevin AndersonNational 
The Entrance LaborGrant McBride4.9–17.312.5Chris SpenceLiberal 
Wollondilly LaborPhil Costa3.3–18.014.7Jai RowellLiberal 
Wyong LaborDavid Harris6.9–9.42.5Darren WebberLiberal 

Every seat in New South Wales swung to the Coalition on a two-party-preferred basis. The Coalition won the largest government in New South Wales history in a huge landslide, while Labor suffered the largest swing against a sitting government anywhere in Australia (and on any level) since World War II, as well as one of the worst defeats of a state government since Federation. This led to 12 consecutive years of Coalition government in New South Wales (the longest Coalition government and the third-longest state government overall in New South Wales history), until the Coalition was narrowly defeated in 2023.

The Liberals alone won more first preference votes than Labor (usually it takes both Coalition parties, the Liberals and the Nationals, to have a higher first preference vote than Labor).

Labor only had two safe seats after the defeat, both of which were in Western Sydney. The seats were Bankstown (on a 10.3% margin) and Liverpool (on a 14.7% margin). Labor only held five seats outside of Sydney (Cessnock, Keira, Shellharbour, Wallsend and Wollongong).

Ultimately, the Liberals won 29 seats from Labor (Blue Mountains, Camden, Campbelltown, Charlestown, Coogee, Drummoyne, East Hills, Gosford, Granville, Heathcote, Kiama, Londonderry, Maitland, Menai, Miranda, Mulgoa, Newcastle, Oatley, Parramatta, Riverstone, Rockdale, Smithdale, Strathfield, Swansea, The Entrance, Wollondilly and Wyong) while the Nationals won two seats from Labor (Bathurst and Monaro). The Nationals gained three seats from independents (Dubbo, Port Macquarie and Tamworth), which were Nationals seats held by personally popular independents. It is likely that Port Macquarie and Tamworth were regained by the Nationals easily due to a move by two independents in the federal seats of Lyne (Rob Oakeshott) and New England (Tony Windsor), which partially overlap with the respective state seats, which angered the locals, who are mostly liberal conservatives in some of the most safely-held Coalition seats in the country. The move that supposedly caused this was the decision of these two independents to support Julia Gillard, who formed a Labor minority government, over the Coalition under Tony Abbott (although Oakeshott stated that he would have supported the Coalition if Malcolm Turnbull was their leader instead of Abbott). Oakeshott and Windsor were personally popular in these seats (with Oakeshott even being an ex-National), but on traditional two-party-preferred contests, the Nationals were well ahead of Labor. The member for Port Macquarie, Peter Besseling, was friends with Oakeshott and previously worked as his advisor, thus angering Port Macquarie locals. Independents held just three seats after the election: Lake Macquarie, Northern Tablelands and Sydney.

The Greens won their first ever seat in New South Wales, the formerly-safe Labor seat of Balmain in inner-city Sydney, despite the Liberals winning the first preference vote.

See also

External links

Notes and References

  1. News: A turning point for the Libs . The Daily Telegraph . 20 October 2008 . 20 May 2009 .
  2. News: . Liar Paluzzano resigns from parliament . The Daily Telegraph . 7 May 2010 . 8 May 2010.
  3. News: Libs claim victory in Penrith . The Sydney Morning Herald . Fairfax Media . AAP . 19 June 2010 . 19 June 2010 .
  4. Web site: Writs of Elections . Government Gazette . Government of New South Wales . 5 March 2011 . 24 March 2011 . https://web.archive.org/web/20110513183139/http://www.nsw.gov.au/sites/default/files/No_25_of_2011_0.pdf . 13 May 2011 . dead.
  5. News: NSW election campaign launch: Labor beats Coalition to the punch . The Sydney Morning Herald . Fairfax Media . Nicholls, Sean . 4 February 2011 . 20 February 2011.
  6. News: Labor election strategy already failing the test . . News Limited . . 12 February 2011 . 20 February 2011.
  7. News: Coalition kicks off NSW election campaign . Telegraph — News Ltd . 20 February 2011 . 25 March 2011.
  8. News: Labor steels itself for disaster with day to go . The Sydney Morning Herald . Fairfax Media . 20 February 2011 . 25 March 2011.
  9. Web site: NSW Labor may only win 13 seats: ABC PM 25 March 2011 . Abc.net.au . 25 March 2011 . 16 April 2011.
  10. Web site: Avoid scandals, O'Farrell tells his MPs . News.smh.com.au . 30 March 2011 . 16 April 2011.
  11. News: 27 March 2011 . Legislative Council, NSW election 2011 . ABC News . Australian Broadcasting Corporation . 27 March 2011.
  12. News: 27 March 2011 . Upper House shift from left to right . ABC News . Australian Broadcasting Corporation . 27 March 2011.
  13. News: NSW must emerge from Labor's heart of darkness . News Limited . The Australian . 25 March 2011. 28 March 2011.
  14. News: It's time for a state cleanout . The Daily Telegraph . 25 March 2011. 28 March 2011.
  15. News: NSW is overdue for change and renewal . Fairfax Media . The Sydney Morning Herald . 25 March 2011. 28 March 2011.