| Champ: |  John Isner |
| Runner: | Donald Young |
| Score: | 7–5, 6–4 |
| Type: | singles doubles |
See main article: article and 2009 Tallahassee Tennis Challenger. Bobby Reynolds was the defender of championship title; however, he lost to Ryan Sweeting in the first round.
John Isner won in the final 7–5, 6–4, against Donald Young.