Following the signature of the first MLS players' union contract, the MLS Superdraft was limited to four rounds. As a result, the Supplemental Draft was re-incarnated to hold the additional rounds. The 2005 MLS supplemental draft, held on February 4, 2005, was the first re-incarnation of the MLS supplemental draft. The four-round event followed January's 2005 MLS SuperDraft, as teams filled out their developmental rosters.Expansion clubs Real Salt Lake and Chivas USA received the first picks in each round.
The most notable draft picks include fourth round draft picks Chris Wondolowski, who is one of the top career goalscorers in Major League Soccer with over 140 career MLS goals, and Jeff Larentowicz, who has played more than 380 matches in more than 10 seasons in Major League Soccer.
| width=7% | Pick # ! | width=28% | MLS team ! | width=22% | Player ! | width=12% | ! | Affiliation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | M | Clemson University | ||||||
| 2 | GK | Cal State Dominguez Hills | ||||||
| 3 | F | Ohio State University | ||||||
| 4 | M | University of San Diego | ||||||
| 5 | D | Creighton University | ||||||
| 6 | D | Seton Hall University | ||||||
| 7 | F | University of Rhode Island | ||||||
| 8 | D | University of Virginia | ||||||
| 9 | GK | St. John's University | ||||||
| 10 | Benjamin Benditson | D | Cal State Northridge | |||||
| 11 | F | Hartwick College | ||||||
| 12 | F | Drake University |
| width=7% | Pick # ! | width=30% | MLS team ! | width=20% | Player ! | width=10% | ! | Affiliation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 13 | D | Bucknell University | ||||||
| 14 | M | Virginia Commonwealth University | ||||||
| 15 | GK | Cornell University | ||||||
| 16 | F | University of Maryland | ||||||
| 17 | F | Birmingham Southern College | ||||||
| 18 | GK | Stanford University | ||||||
| 19 | F | UC Santa Barbara | ||||||
| 20 | M | University of Central Florida | ||||||
| 21 | F | Southern Methodist University | ||||||
| 22 | D | Loyola Marymount University | ||||||
| 23 | D | West Virginia University | ||||||
| 24 | D | College of Charleston |
| width=7% | Pick # ! | width=28% | MLS team ! | width=22% | Player ! | width=12% | Position ! | Affiliation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 25 | GK | University of Maryland | ||||||
| 26 | M | University of California | ||||||
| 27 | M | Rutgers University | ||||||
| 28 | D | University of San Francisco | ||||||
| 29 | D | University of California | ||||||
| 30 | GK | Temple University | ||||||
| 31 | F | Alabama A&M University | ||||||
| 32 | D | St. John's University | ||||||
| 33 | M | University of Connecticut | ||||||
| 34 | Ryan Shaw | F | University of California, Davis | |||||
| 35 | Doug Lascody | M | Southwest Missouri State University | |||||
| 36 | GK | Stanford University |
No trades reported.
| width=7% | Pick # ! | width=28% | MLS team ! | width=25% | Player ! | width=10% | ! | Affiliation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 37 | D | University of Akron | ||||||
| 38 | GK | UC Santa Barbara | ||||||
| 39 | D | Liberty University | ||||||
| 40 | M | Ohio State University | ||||||
| 41 | M | Chico State University | ||||||
| 42 | F | Southern Connecticut State | ||||||
| 43 | D | Georgetown University | ||||||
| 44 | F | Marquette University | ||||||
| 45 | D | Brown University | ||||||
| 46 | F | University of Cincinnati | ||||||
| 47 | D | Wake Forest University | ||||||
| 48 | M | American University |
No trades reported.