| Team | Player | Position | College | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Long Island | Sal Locasio | Defense | Massachusetts | |
| 2 | New Jersey | Trevor Tierney | Goalkeeper | Princeton | |
| 3 | Baltimore | Adam Borcz | Midfielder | Navy | |
| 4 | Long Island | Eric Wedin | Midfielder | Johns Hopkins | |
| 5 | Rochester (from Boston) | Chris Cercy | Midfielder | Syracuse | |
| 6 | Baltimore (from Bridgeport) | Midfielder | Loyola | ||
| 7 | Bridgeport (from Rochester) | Attackman | Rutgers | ||
| 8 | Boston | Midfielder | Denver | ||
| 9 | Long Island | Rob Mulligan | Goalkeeper | Syracuse | |
| 10 | Baltimore | Jeff Sonke | Attackman | North Carolina | |
| 11 | New Jersey | Chris Malone | Midfielder | Maryland | |
| 12 | Bridgeport | Rodger Colbert | Defense | Georgetown | |
| 13 | Rochester | Steve Bishko | Midfielder | Notre Dame | |
| 14 | New Jersey | Rob Torti | Midfielder | Princeton | |
| 15 | Baltimore | Defense | Johns Hopkins | ||
| 16 | Long Island | Brandon Testa | Defense | Johns Hopkins | |
| 17 | Boston | Mike Henehan | Midfielder | Georgetown | |
| 18 | Bridgeport | Pat McGinnis | Goalkeeper | Maryland | |
| 19 | Bridgeport | Midfielder | Princeton | ||
| 20 | Boston | Scott Doyle | Midfielder | Georgetown | |
| 21 | Long Island | Rich Kunkel | Midfielder | Massachusetts | |
| 22 | Baltimore | Tom Glatzel | Attackman | Notre Dame | |
| 23 | New Jersey | Justin Berry | Midfielder | Towson | |
| 24 | Rochester | Holt Hopkins | Attackman | Middlebury | |
| 25 | Rochester | Eric Goodberlet | Midfielder | Nazareth | |
| 26 | New Jersey | Todd Minerly | Attackman | Pennsylvania | |
| 27 | Baltimore | David Ulrich | Attackman | Notre Dame | |
| 28 | Long Island | Bobby Horsey | Midfielder | Loyola | |
| 29 | Boston | Kenny Crowley | Defense | Denver | |
| 30 | Bridgeport | Bobby Gormsen | Defense | North Carolina | |