| Awarded For: | 1999–2000 NCAA Division I men's basketball season |
| Previous: | 1999 |
| Main: | All-Americans |
| Next: | 2001 |
The Consensus 2000 College Basketball All-American team, as determined by aggregating the results of four major All-American teams. To earn "consensus" status, a player must win honors from a majority of the following teams: the Associated Press, the USBWA, The Sporting News and the National Association of Basketball Coaches.
| Player | Position | Class | Team | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chris Carrawell | F | Senior | Duke | |
| Marcus Fizer | F | Junior | Iowa State | |
| A. J. Guyton | G | Senior | Indiana | |
| Kenyon Martin | C-F | Senior | Cincinnati | |
| Chris Mihm | C | Junior | Texas | |
| Troy Murphy | F | Sophomore | Notre Dame |
| Player | Position | Class | Team | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Courtney Alexander | G-F | Senior | Fresno State | |
| Shane Battier | F | Junior | Duke | |
| Mateen Cleaves | G | Senior | Michigan State | |
| Scoonie Penn | G | Senior | Ohio State | |
| Morris Peterson | F | Senior | Michigan State | |
| Stromile Swift | C | Sophomore | Louisiana State |
| All-America Team | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| First team | Second team | Third team | ||||
| Player | School | Player | School | Player | School | |
| Associated Press[1] | Stanford | |||||
| Oklahoma | ||||||
| Duke | Ohio State | |||||
| Temple | ||||||
| Michigan State | LSU | |||||
| USBWA[2] | Chris Carrawell | Duke | Courtney Alexander | Fresno State | No third team | |
| Marcus Fizer | Iowa State | Chris Mihm | Texas | |||
| A. J. Guyton | Indiana | Scoonie Penn | Ohio State | |||
| Kenyon Martin | Cincinnati | Morris Peterson | Michigan State | |||
| Troy Murphy | Notre Dame | Stromile Swift | LSU | |||
| NABC[3] | Chris Carrawell | Duke | Shane Battier | Duke | Mateen Cleaves | Michigan State |
| A. J. Guyton | Indiana | Mark Madsen | Stanford | Eduardo Nájera | Oklahoma | |
| Marcus Fizer | Iowa State | Troy Murphy | Notre Dame | Pepe Sanchez | Temple | |
| Kenyon Martin | Cincinnati | Scoonie Penn | Ohio State | Stromile Swift | LSU | |
| Chris Mihm | Texas | Morris Peterson | Michigan State | Syracuse | ||
| Sporting News | Chris Carrawell | Duke | Shane Battier | Duke | No third team | |
| Mateen Cleaves | Michigan State | Marcus Fizer | Iowa State | |||
| A. J. Guyton | Indiana | Chris Mihm | Texas | |||
| Kenyon Martin | Cincinnati | Troy Murphy | Notre Dame | |||
| Morris Peterson | Michigan State | Scoonie Penn | Ohio State | |||
AP Honorable Mention:[4]