| Offense |
|---|
| Position | First team | Second team |
|---|
| Quarterback | Babe Parilli, Patriots (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI) | Len Dawson, Chiefs (AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI) | | Halfback | N/A | Abner Haynes, Chiefs (AP, NEA, NYDN)
Sid Blanks, Oilers (UPI) | | Fullback | Cookie Gilchrist, Bills (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Keith Lincoln, Chargers (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI) | Matt Snell, Jets (AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI) | | Wide receiver | Lance Alworth, Chargers (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Charlie Hennigan, Oilers (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Art Powell, Raiders (AFL) | Art Powell, Raiders (AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Elbert Dubenion, Bills (AP, NYDN)
Gino Cappelletti, Boston (NEA, UPI) | | Tight end | Fred Arbanas, Chiefs (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI) | Dave Kocourek, Chargers (AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI) | | Tackle | Ron Mix, Chargers (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Stew Barber, Bills (AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Jim Tyrer, Chiefs (AFL) | Jim Tyrer, Chiefs (AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Eldon Danenhauer, Broncos (AP, NYDN)
Sherman Plunkett, Jets (NEA)
Sonny Bishop, Oilers (UPI) | | Guard | Billy Shaw, Bills (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Billy Neighbors, Patriots (AP, NYDN, UPI)
Bob Talamini, Oilers (AFL, NEA) | Bob Talamini, Oilers (AP, NYDN, UPI)
Charlie Long, Patriots (NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Wayne Hawkins, Raiders (AP)
Bob Mischak, Raiders (NEA) | | Center | Jim Otto, Raiders (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI) | Jon Morris, Patriots (AP, NEA, NYDN)
Mike Hudock, Jets (UPI) | |
| | Defense |
|---|
| Position | First team | Second team |
|---|
| Defensive end | Earl Faison, Chargers (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Larry Eisenhauer, Patriots (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN)
Bobby Bell, Chiefs (UPI) | Bobby Bell, Chiefs (AP, NEA, NYDN)
Bob Dee, Patriots (AP, NYDN)
Tom Day, Bills (NEA)
Don Floyd, Oilers (UPI)
Larry Eisenhauer, Patriots (UPI) | | Defensive tackle | Tom Sestak, Bills (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Ernie Ladd, Chargers (AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Jerry Mays, Chiefs (AFL) | Buck Buchanan, Chiefs (AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Jerry Mays, Chiefs (AP, NEA)
Houston Antwine, Patriots (NYDN, UPI) | | Middle linebacker | Nick Buoniconti, Boston (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI) | Sherrill Headrick, Chiefs (AP, NEA)
Archie Matsos, Raiders (NYDN)
Chuck Allen, Chargers (UPI) | | Outside linebacker | Larry Grantham, Jets (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Mike Stratton, Bills (AP, NYDN, UPI)
Tom Addison, Patriots (AFL, NEA) | Frank Buncom, Chargers (AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Tom Addison, Patriots (AP, NYDN, UPI)
John Tracey, Bills (NEA)
Mike Stratton, Bills (NEA) | | Cornerback | Willie Brown, Broncos (AFL, AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Dave Grayson, Chiefs (AFL, AP, NYDN)
Dick Westmoreland, Chargers (NEA)
Fred Williamson, Raiders (UPI) | Dick Westmoreland, Chargers (AP, NYDN, UPI)
Dave Grayson, Chiefs (NEA, UPI)
Pete Jaquess, Oilers (AP)
Butch Byrd, Bills (NEA)
Fred Williamson, Raiders (NYDN) | | Safety | Ron Hall, Patriots (AP, NEA, NYDN, UPI)
Dainard Paulson, Jets (AFL, NEA, UPI)
George Saimes, Bills (AP, NYDN)
Fred Glick, Oilers (AFL) | Bobby Hunt, Chiefs (AP, NYDN)
Dainard Paulson, Jets (AP, NYDN)
George Saimes, Bills (NEA, UPI)
Fred Glick, Oilers (NEA)
Goose Gonsoulin, Broncos (UPI) | |
| |
