1948–49 Challenge Cup Explained

1948–49 Challenge Cup
Duration:5 rounds
No Of Teams:32
Season:1948–49
Season Champs: Bradford Northern
Season Champ Name:Winners
Prevseason Link:1947–48 Challenge Cup
Prevseason Year:1947–48
Nextseason Link:1949–50 Challenge Cup
Nextseason Year:1949–50

The 1948–49 Challenge Cup was the 48th staging of rugby league's oldest knockout competition, the Challenge Cup.[1]

The 29 clubs of the rugby league were joined in the competition by three junior clubs, one each from Yorkshire, Lancashire and Cumberland; respectively these junior clubs were Normanton, Vine Tavern and Broughton Moor.

First round

The first round ties were two-legged and were to be played on consecutive weekends in February 1949. The draw was made on 17 January 1949.[2] The tie between Vine Tavern and York was drawn to have the leg at York played first but the clubs agreed to reverse the tie to enable Vine Tavern to play their home leg Knowsley Road, home of nearby St. Helens.[3] Featherstone's tie with Swinton should have had the first leg played at Featherstone. However Featherstone invoked their right under the competition rules as the first drawn club to decide where the first leg would be played and insisted that it was played at Swinton to avoid clashes with the home ties of neighbouring clubs, Normanton and Castleford, this was despite Swinton's opposition to the switch.[4]

The first leg ties were played on Saturday 12 February.

width=19%Homewidth=6%Scorewidth=19%Awaywidth=10%Referee[5]
Bradford Northern3–4St. HelensG. S. Phillips
Castleford10–2BramleyC. F. Appleton
Dewsbury9–6BarrowN. T. Railton
Swinton15–2Featherstone RoversH. Holland
Huddersfield4–5Rochdale HornetsT. E. Rees
Hull F.C.4–0HalifaxP. Cowell
Hunslet22–0SalfordF. Smith
Leeds16–2BatleyW. Stockley
Liverpool Stanley3–32Wakefield TrinityT. W. Hemmings
Normanton4–9Belle Vue RangersR. S. Abram
Oldham30–0Broughton MoorF. Cotton
Warrington17–7Hull Kingston RoversL. Thorpe
Whitehaven0–0KeighleyH. Squires
Wigan11–12LeighA. S. Dobson
Workington Town6–7WidnesA. Hill
Vine Tavern4–11YorkD. Halliday
Source:[6]

The second leg ties were played on Saturday 19 February.

width=19%Homewidth=6%Scorewidth=19%Awaywidth=10%Refereewidth=6%Aggregate score
St. Helens0–5Bradford NorthernA. S. Dobson4–8
Bramley2–10CastlefordP. Cowell4–20
Barrow13–9DewsburyW. Hemmings19–18
Featherstone Rovers13–10SwintonR. L. Thorpe15–25
Rochdale Hornets0–11HuddersfieldF. Cottam5–15
Halifax10–0Hull F.C.G. S. Phillips10–4
Salford11–10HunsletA. Howgate11–32
Batley4–7LeedsC. F. Appleton6–23
Wakefield Trinity41–12Liverpool StanleyS. W. Stockley73–15
Belle Vue Rangers12–0NormantonT. Armitage21–4
Broughton Moor2–35OldhamL. J. Dalby2–65
Hull Kingston Rovers5–28WarringtonN. T. Railton12–45
Keighley19–9WhitehavenF. Smith19–9
Leigh4–5WiganA. Hill16–16
Widnes0–10Workington TownS. Adams7–16
York17–3Vine TavernB. Lister28–7
Source:[7]

The tie between Leigh and Wigan ended in controversy. In January the cup committee recommended that ties ending with the scores level should play 20 minutes of extra time (10 minutes each way) with a replay only being required if the scores remained tied after this period.[8] This recommendation as accepted by the Rugby League Council but was not, officially, made known to referees. Therefore, at the end of the second leg the referee in the Leigh v Wigan tie, Alfred Hill, ended the game after 80 minutes and did not play any extra time.[9] The second leg was declared null and void by the Rugby League Council and a replay ordered for the following Saturday at a neutral venue, Swinton's Station Road with only the score from the first leg being taken forward into the replay.[10]

The replay, refereed by W. Hemmings,[11] was won 10–4 by Wigan who therefore went forward to the second round 21–16 on aggregate.[12]

Second round

The second round draw was made on 21 February 1949 with ties to be played on Saturday 5 March.[13] On the day the game between Wigan and Wakefield was postponed due to snowfall and was played the following Wednesday, 9 March, instead.[14]

width=19%Homewidth=6%Scorewidth=19%Awaywidth=10%Referee[15]
Barrow13–2Keighley
Belle Vue Rangers8–3WarringtonA. S. Dobson
Bradford Northern11–5CastlefordF. Smith
Halifax5–0SwintonW. Stockley
Huddersfield3–0Workington TownC. F. Appleton
Leeds14–8HunsletP. Cowll
York3–4OldhamG. S. Phillips
Wigan37–2Wakefield TrinityS. Adams
Source:[16] [17]

Third round

The draw for the third round was made on 7 March with ties to be played on Saturday 19 March.[18]

width=19%Homewidth=6%Scorewidth=19%Awaywidth=10%Referee[19]
Barrow8–7WiganM. Coates
Bradford Northern8–7Belle Vue RangersG. S. Phillips
Leeds9–20HuddersfieldC. F. Appleton
Oldham2–7HalifaxA. S. Dobson
Source:[20]

Semi-finals

The semi-final draw was made on 21 March with neutral venues being announced immediately after the completion of the draw, the ties were played on 2 April.[21]

width=19%Homewidth=6%Scorewidth=19%Awaywidth=10%Venuewidth=10%Referee
Bradford Northern10–0BarrowStation Road, SwintonA. S. Dobson
Halifax11–10HuddersfieldOdsal Stadium, BradfordG. S. Phillips
Source:[22] [23]

Final

The Challenge Cup tournament's final was to be played by Bradford and Halifax at Wembley Stadium. Bradford won the game 12–0 in the final played in front of a world record rugby league crowd of 95,000.[24] Trevor Foster and Eric Batten scored the tries for Bradford and Ernest Ward kicked three goals as well as winning the Lance Todd Trophy for man-of-the-match.[25]

This was Bradford's fourth Cup Final win in seven final appearances including one win and one loss during World War II.[26]

Bradford NorthernPositionHalifax
FBDenis Chalkley
style=background:#eee;"WGArthur Daniels
style=background:#eee;"CEGareth Price (c)
style=background:#eee;"CEPaddy Reid
style=background:#eee;"WGEnoka Macdonald
style=background:#eee;"SOGeorge Kenny
style=background:#eee;"SHStan Kielty
style=background:#eee;"PR
style=background:#eee;"HKAlvin Ackerley
style=background:#eee;"PRMichael Condon
style=background:#eee;"SRJack Pansegrouw
style=background:#eee;"SRDesmond Healy
style=background:#eee;"LFFrank Mawson
style=background:#eee;"Arthur Atkinson

Notes and References

  1. Web site: Challenge Cup 1948/49. Rugby League Project.
  2. News: Cup draw keeps Rugby League giants apart . . 18 January 1949 . 3 . ((31,635)) . subscription . British Newspaper Archive.
  3. News: Cuptie reversed . . 20 January 1949 . 6 . ((19,709)) . subscription . British Newspaper Archive.
  4. News: Swinton dislike Featherstone's "Fast One" . . 3 February 1949 . 3 . ((31,649)) . subscription . British Newspaper Archive.
  5. News: Referees for Rugby League Cup games . . 19 January 1949 . 8 . ((18,161)) . subscription . British Newspaper Archive.
  6. News: Rugby League Cup - First Round, First leg . . ((31,658)) . 14 February 1949 . 3 . subscription . British Newspaper Archive.
  7. News: Rugby League Cup - First Round, Second Leg . . ((31,664)) . 21 February 1949 . 3 . subscription . British Newspaper Archive.
  8. News: Saturday R.L. cup replays . . 13 January 1949 . 14 . ((18,156)) . subscription . British Newspaper Archive.
  9. News: R.L. Cup replay decision causes a protest . . 21 February 1949 . 3 . ((31,664)) . subscription . British Newspaper Archive.
  10. News: Wigan—Leigh cup-tie: last night's surprise . . 3 . 22 February 1949 . ((31,665)) . subscription . British Newspaper Archive.
  11. News: Wigan-Leigh protest . . 22 February 1949 . 12 . ((18,190)) . subscription . British Newspaper Archive.
  12. News: Narrow escape for Wigan . . 28 February 1949 . 3 . ((31,670)) . subscription . British Newspaper Archive.
  13. News: Leeds at home to Hunslet in Rugby League Cup: Yorkshire clubs favoured in second round draw . . 21 February 1949 . 8 . ((18,189)) . subscription . British Newspaper Archive.
  14. News: Will Trinity object to midweek cup-tie? . . ((31,676)) . 7 March 1949 . 3 . subscription . British Newspaper Archive.
  15. News: Referees for round two . . 22 February 1949 . 12 . ((18,190)) . subscription . British Newspaper Archive.
  16. News: Rugby League Cup - Second Round . . ((31,676)) . 7 March 1949 . 3 . subscription . British Newspaper Archive.
  17. News: Trinity's heaviest-ever Cup defeat . . 10 March 1949 . 3 . ((31,679)) . subscription . British Newspaper Archive.
  18. News: Rugby League Cup Draw . . 7 March 1949 . 4 . ((19,748)) . subscription . British Newspaper Archive.
  19. News: Pudsey League referee's advance . . 9 March 1949 . 8 . ((18,203)) . subscription . British Newspaper Archive.
  20. News: Rugby League Cup (Third Round) . . 19 March 1949 . 19 . ((18,011)) . subscription . British Newspaper Archive.
  21. News: Huddersfield to meet Halifax in Cup semi-final . . 21 March 1949 . 8 . ((18,213)) . subscription . British Newspaper Archive.
  22. News: Ernest Ward again . . 4 April 1949 . 3 . ((31,700)) . subscription . British Newspaper Archive.
  23. News: Halifax never gave up . . 4 April 1949 . 3 . ((31,700)) . subscription . British Newspaper Archive.
  24. News: Tom Goodman's League Column . . 9 . 4 May 1950 .
  25. News: Ernest Ward star of the Cup Final . . 9 May 1949 . 3 . ((31,729)) . subscription . British Newspaper Archive.
  26. Web site: RFL All Time Records . 7 August 2009 . https://web.archive.org/web/20090403144104/http://www.therfl.co.uk/challengecup/page.php?areaid=64 . 3 April 2009 . dead .