| Awarded For: | 1911–12 NCAA men's basketball season |
| Previous: | 1911 |
| Main: | All-Americans |
| Next: | 1913 |
The 1912 College Basketball All-American team, as chosen retroactively by the Helms Athletic Foundation.[1] The player highlighted in gold was chosen as the Helms Foundation College Basketball Player of the Year retroactively in 1944.
| Player | Team | |
|---|---|---|
| Claus Benson | Columbia | |
| Thomas Canfield | St. Lawrence | |
| Lewis Castle | Syracuse | |
| Fred Gieg | Swarthmore | |
| Ernst Mensel | Dartmouth | |
| Emil Schradieck | Colgate | |
| Alphonse Schumacher | Dayton | |
| Rufus Sisson | Dartmouth | |
| Otto Stangel | Wisconsin | |
| William Turner | Penn |