| District | Incumbent | Party | First elected | Result | Candidates[1] | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jonathan Dayton | Federalist | 1791 | Incumbent re-elected. | nowrap rowspan=5 | √ Jonathan Dayton (Federalist) 15.8% √ Mark Thomson (Federalist) 10.4% √ James H. Imlay (Federalist) 9.6% √ James Schureman (Federalist) 9.3% √ Thomas Sinnickson (Federalist) 9.1% Aaron Kitchell (Democratic-Republican) 8.6% Joseph Bloomfield (Democratic-Republican) 5.5% James Linn (Democratic-Republican) 5.3% Ebenezer Elmer (Democratic-Republican) 4.8% John Condit (Democratic-Republican) 4.6% William Crane (Federalist) 3.5% Joseph Cooper (Democratic-Republican) 3.5% William Helms (Democratic-Republican) 2.8% Thomas Lowrey (Federalist) 1.5% Jonathan Elmer (Federalist) 1.3% | ||
| Mark Thomson | Federalist | 1794 | Incumbent re-elected. | ||||
| Aaron Kitchell | Federalist | 1794 (special) | Incumbent lost re-election. New member elected. Federalist hold. | ||||
| Thomas Henderson | Federalist | 1794 | Incumbent lost re-election. New member elected. Federalist hold. | ||||
| Isaac Smith | Federalist | 1794 | Incumbent retired. New member elected. Federalist hold. |