*Dyēus Explained

Indo-European languages: *Dyḗus (lit. "daylight-sky-god"), also Indo-European languages: *Dyḗus ph₂tḗr (lit. "father daylight-sky-god"), is the reconstructed name of the daylight-sky god in Proto-Indo-European mythology. Indo-European languages: *Dyēus was conceived as a divine personification of the bright sky of the day and the seat of the gods, the Indo-European languages: *deywṓs. Associated with the vast diurnal sky and with the fertile rains, Indo-European languages: *Dyēus was often paired with

, the Earth Mother, in a relationship of union and contrast.

While its existence is not directly attested by archaeological or written materials, Indo-European languages: *Dyēus is considered by scholars the most securely reconstructed deity of the Indo-European pantheon, as identical formulas referring to him can be found among the subsequent Indo-European languages and myths of the Vedic Indo-Aryans, Latins, Greeks, Phrygians, Messapians, Thracians, Illyrians, Albanians and Hittites.

Name

Etymology

The divine name *Dyēus derives from the stem *dyeu-, denoting the "diurnal sky" or the "brightness of the day" (in contrast to the darkness of the night), ultimately from the root *di or dei- ("to shine, be bright"). Cognates in Indo-European languages revolving around the concepts of "day", "sky" and "deity" and sharing the root *dyeu- as an etymon, such as Sanskrit dyumán- 'heavenly, shining, radiant',[1] suggest that Dyēus referred to the vast and bright sky of the day conceived as a divine entity among Proto-Indo-European speakers.

A vṛddhi-derivative appears in *deywós ("celestial"), the common word for "god" in Proto-Indo-European. In classic Indo-European, associated with the late Khvalynsk culture (3900–3500), *Dyēus also had the meaning of "Heaven", whereas it denoted "god" in general (or the Sun-god in particular) in the Anatolian tradition. The suffix-derivative *diwyós ("divine") is also attested in Latin, Greek and Sanskrit. The noun Indo-European languages: *deynos ("day"), interpreted as a back-formation of *deywós, has descendant cognates in Albanian Albanian: din ("break of the day"),[2] Vedic Sanskrit dína- "day" and divé-dive ("day by day"), Lithuanian dienà and Latvian dìena ("day"), Slavic dъnъ ("day") or Slavic Poludnitsa ("Lady Midday"),[3] Latin Dies, goddess of the day and counterpart to Greek Hemera, Hittite siwat ("day"), Palaic Tīyat- ("Sun, day"), Ancient Greek endios ("midday"), Old Armenian tiw (տիւ, "bright day"), Old Irish Irish, Old (to 900);: noenden ("nine-day period"), Welsh Welsh: heddyw ("today").

While the Greek goddess Pandeia or Pandia (Greek, Ancient (to 1453);: Πανδία, Πανδεία, "all brightness") may have been another name for the Moon Goddess Selene,[4] her name still preserves the root *di-/*dei-, meaning "to shine, be bright".[5]

Epithets

The most constant epithet associated with *Dyēus is "father" (*ph₂tḗr). The term "Father Dyēus" was inherited in the Vedic Dyáuṣ Pitṛ́, Greek Zeus Patēr, Illyrian Dei-pátrous, Roman Jupiter (*Djous patēr), even in the form of "dad" or "papa" in the Scythian Papaios for Zeus, or the Palaic expression Tiyaz papaz. The epithet *Ph₂tḗr Ǵenh1-tōr ("Father Procreator") is also attested in the Vedic, Iranian, Greek, and perhaps the Roman ritual traditions.

Role

Due to his celestial nature, *Dyēus is often described as "all-seeing" or "with wide vision" in Indo-European myths. It is unlikely however that he was in charge of the supervision of justice and righteousness, as it was the case for Zeus or the Indo-Iranian MithraVaruna duo, but he was suited to serve at least as a witness to oaths and treaties. Proto-Indo-Europeans also visualized the sun as the "lamp of Dyēus" or the "eye of Dyēus", as seen in various reflexes: "the god's lamp" in Euripides' Medea, "heaven's candle" in Beowulf, "the land of Hatti's torch" (the Sun-goddess of Arinna) in a Hittite prayer, Helios as the eye of Zeus,[7] [8] Hvare-khshaeta as the eye of Ahura Mazda, and the sun as "God's eye" in Romanian folklore.[9]

Consort

While Hausos and the Divine Twins are generally considered the offsprings of *Dyēus alone, some scholars have proposed a spouse-goddess reconstructed as *Diwōnā or *Diuōneh₂,[10] with a possible descendant in Zeus's consort Dione. A thematic echo occurs in the Vedic tradition as Indra's wife Indrānī displays a similar jealous and quarrelsome disposition under provocation. A second descendant may be found in Dia, a mortal said to unite with Zeus in a Greek myth. After the mating of Dia's husband Ixion with the phantom of Hera, the spouse of Zeus, the story leads ultimately to the birth of the Centaurs (who may be seen as reminiscent of the Divine Twins, sons of *Dyēus). Another reflex may be found in the Mycenaean Greek Diwia, possibly a feminine counterpart of Zeus attested in the second part of the 2nd millennium BC and which may have survived in the Pamphylian dialect of Asia Minor.[11] [12] [13] The reconstruction is however only based upon the Greek—and to a lesser extent the Vedic—tradition, and it remains therefore not secured.

If the female goddesses Hera, Juno, Frigg and Shakti share a common association with marriage and fertility, Mallory and Adams note however that "these functions are much too generic to support the supposition of a distinct PIE 'consort goddess' and many of the 'consorts' probably represent assimilations of earlier goddesses who may have had nothing to do with marriage."

Evidence

Cognates deriving either from the stem *dyeu- ("daylight, bright sky"), the epithet *Dyēus Ph2ter ("Father Sky"), the vṛddhi-derivative *deiwós ("celestial", a "god"), the derivative *diwyós ("divine"), or the back-formation Indo-European languages: *deynos (a "day") are among the most widely attested in Indo-European languages.

Descendants

*d(e)i-, 'to shine, be bright',

*dyauš,[14]

Dyáuṣ (द्यौष्), the god of Heaven, and dyú (द्यु), the common word for "heaven",

dyaoš (), "heaven", mentioned in a single verse of the Avesta;[15] Young Avestan: diiaoš, "hell", as a result of the Zoroastrian religious reformation,

di-we (/diwei/), dative case of an otherwise scarcely attested name,

ti-wo, interpreted as pertaining to Zeus, and the possible genitive Diwoi,[16] [17] [18] [19]

Zeus (Ζεύς; gen. Diós), the god of the Sky; also Boeotian Lac., Corinth., Rhod. dialects: Deús (Δεύς),

*d(i)jous,

Dioue (or loue), Dijovis (diovis),

Diúvei (Διουϝει), genitive singular,[20] [21]

Di or Dei (Grabouie/Graboue), attested in the Iguvine Tablets,

Ioviois (Pvclois) and Ioveis (Pvcles), interpreted as a calque of the Greek theonym Diós-kouroi,[22] [23]

*diéu-, *diu-, a "god",

šīuš, a "god" or the Sun-God;, Hittite personification of day; another deity named Šiušummiš is mentioned in the Anitta text.[24]

tiuna, "divine, a god",

ciw-, a "god"; Lefs or Lévs, the Lydian Zeus.[25] [26]

*Tiw, the Sky- or Thunder-god,

tiw (Տիւ), "day, daytime, morning" and ti, "day" (only in erk-ti "two days"); and possibly also ciacan "rainbow" (according to Martirosyan, from *Ti(w)-a- attached to *can- "sign, omen", thus "the sign of the Sky/Thunder-god"),

dei-, meaning "heaven" or "God", as in Dei-pátrous, the "sky-father",

*dyēs,

Zis or Dis, the sky-god,

Zojz, a sky and lightning god; the root *d(e)i- may also be found in Perën-di "Heaven", "God" (with a suffix -di attached to per-en-, an extension of PIE *per- "to strike"),

Zi-, Diu-, and Dias- (in personal names),

Tiy-,[27]

Tiyes and the place name Tium (Τιεῖον).[28]

"Sky-Father" epithet

Ritual and formulaic expressions stemming from the form *Dyēus Ph2ter ("Father Dyēus") were inherited in the following liturgic and poetic traditions:

*dyēus ph2tḗr, 'Father Sky' (voc. *dyeu ph2ter, "O Father Sky"),

Zeus Patēr (Ζεῦς πατήρ; voc. Ζεῦ πάτερ),

*Dyauš-pHtar,

Dyáuṣ-pitā́ (voc. Dyáuṣ-pitṛ́, द्यौष्पितृ),

*Djous-patēr > *Dijēs-patēr (voc. *Djow-patēr),

Dies Pater,

Diespiter (from *Dijēs-patēr); Iūpiter (from *Djow-patēr), archaic Iovispater, later Iuppiter,

Dípatír, Umbrian: Iupater (dat. Iuve patre), South Picene: dipater (gen. dipoteres),[29]

Deipaturos, recorded by Hesychius as Δειπάτυροϛ (Deipáturos), a god worshiped in Tymphaea.

Other reflexes are variants that have retained both linguistic descendants of the stem *dyeu- ("sky") alongside the original structure "Father God". Some traditions have replaced the epithet *ph2ter with the nursery word papa ("dad, daddy"):

Tātis tiwaz, "Daddy Tiwaz", the Sun-god,

Tiyaz papaz, "Papa Tiyaz", the Sun-god,

Papaios (Papa Zios), "father Zeus", the god of the Sky,

in Dagdae Oll-athair, "Great Father the Dagda" (from the Proto-Celtic formula *sindos dago-dēwos ollo fātir, "Great Father the Good God").

Other variants are less secured:

attas Isanus, "Father Sun-god"; the name of the sky-god was replaced with a Hattic sun-god loan, but the original structure of the formula left intact,

Debess tēvs, "Father of Heaven",

Óðinn Alföðr, "Odin, All-Father" or "Odin Father of All",[30] [31]

Stribogŭ, "Father God",

Zot, "lord" or "God", epithet of Zojz, the sky-father (generally thought to be derived from Proto-Albanian Albanian: *dźie̅u ̊ a(t)t-, "heavenly father";[32] although the etymology Albanian: *w(i)tš- pati-, "lord of the house", has also been proposed),

kauṃ-ñäkte, 'sun, sun-god'.

"Celestial" derivations

Cognates stemming from *deywós, a vṛddhi-derivation of *dyēus (the sky-god), are attested in the following traditions:

*daivá (daiua), a "god",

devá (देव), meaning "heavenly, divine, anything of excellence", and devi, female title meaning "goddess";[33]

daēva (daēuua), a term for "demons" in Zoroastrianism, as a result of a religious reformation that degraded the status of prior deities,

daiva meaning "false deities, demons",

*deiwas,

*deivas,

Diēvas, supreme god of the sky,

Dìews (or Deywis), Latvian: Dievs, and the Baltic Dievaitis ("Little God" or "Prince"), a name used to refer to the Thunder God Perkūnas,[34] or to the Moon God Mėnuo.[35] [36] [37]

*tīwaz (pl. *tīwōz), a word for "god" that probably also served as a title (*Tīwaz, "God") that came to be associated with a specific deity whose original name is now lost,

Týr, associated with justice; the plural tívar survived as a poetic word for 'the gods', and týr appears in kennings for Odin and Thor, such as in the Odin's names Sigtýr ("victory-god"), Gautatýr ("god of the Geats"), Fimbultýr ("powerful god"), or Hertýr ("army-god"),

Tīw (or Tīg), Old High German: Zio (or *Ziu), a god,

*Teiws, a deity reconstructed from the associated rune ᛏ (Tyz),

*deiwos, a "god, a deity",

Uncoded languages: deivos (Uncoded languages: deiuos), the "gods",

Latin: [[deus]], common name for a "god, a deity"; and Dea ("goddess"), a title assigned to various Roman goddesses like Dea Tacita, Bona Dea or Dea Dia ("Goddess of the Daylight" or "Bright Goddess").[38]

Deus, the god of Christianity in the Vetus Latina and the Vulgate,[39]

deivas, Venetic: deivos, "gods",

deue Decluna, attested in an inscription from Velitrae, possibly from the 3rd century BC.[40] [41]

*dēwos, a "god, a deity", and *dago-dēwos, the "good god", old name of the Dagda,

teiuo, a "god",

dēuos, a "god",

Dubr Duiu ("Water of the Divinity"),[42] evolving into Mod. Welsh Dyfrdwy (River Dee, Wales).[43] The form deva, diva ("goddess") likewise appears in Celtic river names throughout Western Europe,[44] [45] such as in the Scottish rivers Dēoúa (modern-day Dee, Galloway), and Dēouana (Δηουανα; modern-day Don, Aberdeenshire),[46] [47]

día, a "god", and An Dag-da, the druid-god of wisdom,

Dhe ("god"), attested in the modern Sùil Dhé mhóir prayer ("The eye of the great God", in reference to the Sun), featured in Carmina Gadelica.[48]

deiva, dīva, "goddess",

devos.

Other cognates are less secured:

*diva (> *dîvo), perhaps a word for a "good deity" which progressively took the meaning of "miracle", hence "evil being",

divo, Old Polish: dziwo, Russian: dívo, Serbo-Croatian: dîvo, "miracle(s)",

divŭ, "demon", South Slavic: div, "giant, demonic being", Czech: divo-žena, "sorceress, witch", Slovak: divo, "monster", although the Proto-Slavic root *divŭ(jĭ) ("wild") has also been proposed,

Dziewanna, Sorbian: Dživica, Slavic equivalent of Diana,[49] however, other etymologies have been proposed.

Reo, an unknown deity.[21]

Deiba and Deibo, attested in votive inscriptions of altars;[50] taken to mean the "local" or "indigenous" pronunciations of Deae and Deo.[51]

"Divine" derivations

Other cognates deriving from the adjective *diwyós (*dyeu "sky" + yós, a thematic suffix) are attested in the following traditions:

di-wi-jo, di-wi-ja,

dîos (δῖος), "belonging to heaven, godlike", also "belonging to Zeus" in tragedies; feminine Día (Δῖα < *Díw-ya), a goddess venerated in classical times at Phlius and Sicyon, and possibly identified with Hebe, the cup-bearer of the gods,

daeuuiia, "devilish, diabolic",

*dīwī (dat.abl.pl. dīwīs),

dīvus, dīvī, "divine, heavenly, godlike",

Other cognates are less secured:

zana "nymph, goddess".

zână "fairy, goddess".

Legacy

As the pantheons of the individual mythologies related to Proto-Indo-European religion evolved, attributes of *Dyēus seem to have been redistributed to other deities. In Greek and Roman mythology, *Dyēus was the chief god, while the etymological continuant of Dyēus became a very abstract god in Vedic mythology, and his original prominence over other gods largely diluted.

In Albanian tradition

After the first access of the ancestors of the Albanians to the Christian religion in antiquity, the presumable Albanian term for Sky-Father – Zot – has been used for God, the Father and the Son (Christ). In Albanian folk beliefs the peak of the highest mountains like Tomorr in central Albania has been associated with the sky-god Zojz. The enduring sanctity of the mountain, the annual pilgrimage to its summit, and the solemn sacrifice of a white bull by the local people provide abundant evidence that the ancient cult of the sky-god on Mount Tomorr continues through the generations almost untouched by the course of political events and religious changes.

In Slavic tradition

At one point, early Slavs, like some Iranian peoples after the Zoroastrian religious reformation, demonized the Slavic successor of *Dyēus (abandoning this word in the sense of "heaven" at the same time, keeping the word for day, however, and abandoning many of the names of the other Proto-Indo-European gods, replacing them with new Slavic or Iranian names), while not replacing it with any other specific god, as a result of cultural contacts with Iranian peoples in the first millennium BC. Hence, after the process of demonization by the Slavs, *Dyēus is considered to have originated two continuations: *divo ("strange, odd thing") and *divъ ("demon"). The result of this demonization may be Pan-Slavic demons, e.g. Polish and Czech dziwożona, or Div occurring in The Tale of Igor's Campaign.

According to some researchers, at least some of *Dyēuss traits could have been taken over by Svarog (Urbańczyk: Sun-Dažbóg – heavenly fire, Svarožič – earthly fire, Svarog – heaven, lightning). Helmold recalls that the Slavs were also supposed to believe in a god in heaven, who only deals with heavenly matters and commands other gods.

In non-Indo-European traditions

Various loanwords of *deiwós were introduced in non-Indo-European languages, such as Estonian taevas or Finnish taivas ("sky"), borrowed from Proto-Indo-Iranian into these Uralic languages.

Bibliography

Further reading

Notes and References

  1. Vainik . Ene . 2014 . Jumala jälgi ajamas . Following God . Mäetagused . ee . 58 . 7–34 . 10.7592/MT2014.58.vainik. free .
  2. Neri. Sergio. Wörterbuch – DPEWA . din. DPEWA - Digitales Philologisch-Etymologisches Wörterbuch des Altalbanischen. 2021.
  3. Máchal, Jan (1918). "Slavic Mythology". In L. H. Gray (ed.). The Mythology of all Races. III, Celtic and Slavic Mythology. Boston. p. 267.
  4. Book: Hard. Robin. 46. The Routledge Handbook of Greek Mythology: Based on H.J. Rose's "Handbook of Greek Mythology". Rose. H. J.. 2004. Routledge. 978-0-415-18636-0. en.
  5. Fairbanks, Arthur. The Mythology of Greece and Rome. New York: D. Appleton–Century Company. 1907. p. 162. Regarding the meaning of "Pandia", Kerenyi (Kerenyi, Karl. The Gods of the Greeks. Thames & Hudson. 1951), p. 197, says: '"the entirely shining" or the "entirely bright"— doubtless the brightness of nights of full moon.'
  6. Green. Miranda J.. 1990. Pagan Celtic Religion: Archaeology and Myth. Transactions of the Honourable Society of the Cymmrodorion. 13–28.
  7. Sick . David . Mit(h)ra(s) and the Myths of the Sun . Numen . 2004 . 51 . 4 . 432–467 . 10.1163/1568527042500140 .
  8. Book: Bortolani . Ljuba Merlina . Magical Hymns from Roman Egypt: A Study of Greek and Egyptian Traditions of Divinity . 2016 . Cambridge University Press . 978-1-316-67327-0 .
  9. 2012RoAJ...22..155I . The Sun Worship with the Romanians . Ionescu . Doina . Dumitrache . Cristiana . Romanian Astronomical Journal . 2012 . 22 . 2 . 155–166 .
  10. Dunkel. George E.. 1988–1990. Vater Himmels Gattin. Die Sprache. 34. 1–26.
  11. Ventris, Michael; Chadwick, John. Documents in Mycenaean Greek. Cambridge at the University Press. 1956. p. 125.
  12. Book: Bremmer, Jan N.. Gods of Ancient Greece: Identities and Transformations: Identities and Transformations. 2010. Edinburgh University Press. 978-0-7486-4289-2. Bremmer. Jan N.. en. Erskine. Andrew.
  13. Skelton . Christina . Greek-Anatolian Language Contact and the Settlement of Pamphylia . Classical Antiquity . 1 April 2017 . 36 . 1 . 104–129 . 10.1525/ca.2017.36.1.104 . 26362678 .
  14. [Alexander Lubotsky|Lubotsky, Alexander]
  15. Book: De Witt Griswold, Hervey. The Religion of the Rigveda. 1923. H. Milford, Oxford University Press. 978-8120807457. 113. en.
  16. Chaniotis . Angelos . Stavrianopoulou . Eftychia . Epigraphic Bulletin for Greek Religion 1993-1994 . Kernos . 1 January 1997 . 10 . 249–314 . 10.4000/kernos.666 . free .
  17. Yon . Marguerite . Le culte impérial à Salamine . Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes . 2009 . 39 . 1 . 289–308 . 10.3406/cchyp.2009.929 .
  18. Fourrier . Sabine . Lieux de culte à Salamine à l'époque des royaumes . Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes . 2015 . 45 . 1 . 211–223 . 10.3406/cchyp.2015.1635 . 194725375 .
  19. Yon . Marguerite . La ville de Salamine. Fouilles françaises 1964-1974 . The town of Salamis. French excavations 1964-1974 . fr . MOM Éditions . 1993 . 22 . 1 . 139–158 .
  20. Buck, Carl Darling. Comparative Grammar of Greek and Latin. Chicago, Illinois: The University of Chicago Press. 1933. p. 203.
  21. Witczak . Krzysztof Tomasz . On the Indo-European origin of two Lusitanian theonyms (laebo and reve) . Emerita . 30 June 1999 . 67 . 1 . 65–73 . 10.3989/emerita.1999.v67.i1.185 .
  22. Prsper . Blanca . The instrumental case in the thematic noun inflection of Continental Celtic . Historical Linguistics . 1 July 2011 . 124 . 1 . 250–267 . 10.13109/hisp.2011.124.1.250 .
  23. Weinstock . Stefan . Two Archaic Inscriptions from Latium . Journal of Roman Studies . November 1960 . 50 . 1–2 . 112–118 . 10.2307/298293 . 298293 . 161694789 .
  24. Tatishvili, Irene. "Transformations of the Relationship between Hittite Kings and Deities". In: Acts of the IXth International Congress of Hittitology (Çorum, 1–7 September 2014). Vol. II. Çorum: 2019. pp. 1048 and 1050.
  25. Ricl . Marijana . Current Archaeological and Epigraphic Research in the Region of Lydia . Collection de l'Institut des Sciences et Techniques de l'Antiquité . 2013 . 1277 . 2 . 189–195 .
  26. Melchert, Harold Craig. Anatolian Historical Phonology. Amsterdam: Editions Rodopi B. V. 1994. p. 351.
  27. Lubotsky, Alexander M. (2004). "The Phrygian Zeus and the problem of the "Lautverschiebung"". In: Historische Sprachforschung 117(2): 229-237. http://hdl.handle.net/1887/18042
  28. Witczak . K. T. . 1992 . Two Bithynian Deities in the Old and New Phrygian Inscriptional Texts . Folia Orientalia . 29 . 265–271 .
  29. Book: Hamp, Eric P.. Festschrift for Eric P. Hamp. 1997. Institute for the Study of Man. 978-0-941694-62-9. Adams. Douglas Q.. 1. 148. en. 25.
  30. Book: Chaney, William A.. The Cult of Kingship in Anglo-Saxon England: The Transition from Paganism to Christianity. 1970. University of California Press. 978-0-520-01401-5. 34. en.
  31. Book: Wanner, Kevin J.. Snorri Sturluson and the Edda: The Conversion of Cultural Capital in Medieval Scandinavia. 2008. University of Toronto Press. 978-0-8020-9801-6. 157. en.
  32. ; ; ;
  33. Lurker, Manfred. The Routledge Dictionary Of Gods Goddesses Devils And Demons. Routledge. 2004. pp. 49-50.
  34. Book: Bojtár, Endre. Foreword to the Past: A Cultural History of the Baltic People. 1999. Central European University Press. 978-963-9116-42-9. 280–281. en.
  35. Book: Britannica Encyclopedia of World Religions. 2006. Encyclopaedia Britannica. 978-1-59339-266-6. Doniger. Wendy. 711. en.
  36. Vaiškūnas . Jonas . The Moon in Lithuanian Folk Tradition . Folklore: Electronic Journal of Folklore . 2006 . 32 . 157–184 . 10.7592/FEJF2006.32.moon . free .
  37. Jasiūnaitė . Birutė . Maldelės į jauną mėnulį rytų Lietuvos folklore: etnolingvistinis aspektas . Baltistica . 2006 . 41 . 473–488 . lt .
  38. Hunt, Ailsa. Reviving Roman Religion: Sacred Trees in the Roman World. Cambridge Classical Studies. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 2016. pp. 148-149 (footnote nr. 92).
  39. Book: Rey, Alain. Dictionnaire Historique de la langue française. 2011. Nathan. 978-2-321-00013-6. 1079. fr. Alain Rey.
  40. Woodard, Roger D. Myth, Ritual, and the Warrior in Roman and Indo-European Antiquity. Cambridge University Press. 2013. p. 197.
  41. Baldi, Phillip. The Foundations of Latin. New York: Mouton de Gruyter. 2002. pp. 140-142.
  42. Book: Rhys, John. Celtic Folklore. 2016. Cambridge University Press. 978-1-108-07909-9. 441. en.
  43. Wainwright . F. T. . Cledemutha . The English Historical Review . 1950 . 65 . 255 . 203–212 . 10.1093/ehr/LXV.CCLV.203 . 554934 .
  44. Book: James, Alan G.. The Brittonic Language in the Old North: A Guide to the Place-name Evidence. 2014. 2: Guide to the Elements. 139. https://web.archive.org/web/20140911083046/http://www.spns.org.uk/bliton/BLITON2014ii_elements.pdf. 2014-09-11.
  45. MacLeod . Sharon Paice . Mater Deorum Hibernensium: Identity and Cross-Correlation in Early Irish Mythology . Proceedings of the Harvard Celtic Colloquium . 1998 . 18/19 . 340–384 . 20557350 .
  46. Strang. Alastair. 1997. Explaining Ptolemy's Roman Britain. Britannia. 28. 1–30. 10.2307/526763. 526763. 161532105.
  47. Marx. Christian. 2014. Rectification of position data of Scotland in Ptolemy's Geographike Hyphegesis. Survey Review. en. 46. 337. 231–244. 10.1179/1752270613Y.0000000085. 1511.06691. 2014SurRv..46..231M . 119211760.
  48. Carmichael, Alexander. Carmina gadelica: hymns and incantations with illustrative notes on words, rites, and customs, dying and obsolete. Edinburgh; London: Oliver and Boyd. 1928. pp. 316–317.
  49. Book: Kolankiewicz, Leszek.. Dziady : teatr święta zmarłych. 1999. Słowo/obraz terytoria. 83-87316-39-3. Gdańsk. 461–462. 46456548.
  50. Fernandes . Luís da Silva . Carvalho . Pedro Sobral . Figueira . Nádia . Divindades indígenas numa ara inédita de Viseu . Palaeohispanica. Revista sobre lenguas y culturas de la Hispania Antigua . 2009 . 9 . 143–155 . 10.36707/palaeohispanica.v0i9.217 . 31 January 2024 .
  51. Encarnação . José d' . Testemunhos recentes de teónimos pré-romanos na Lusitânia . Antrope . 31 July 2020 . único . 249–273 . 10316/90494 .
  52. Green, C. M. C. Roman Religion and the Cult of Diana at Aricia. New York: Cambridge University Press. 2007. pp. 71–73.